Reviews Archive Ehrliche Meinung zu Fitness Trackern, Sportuhren und Sportelektronik Sun, 10 Nov 2024 15:21:40 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.2 Amazfit T-Rex 3 review: A Fenix challenger for a fraction of the price https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/amazfit-t-rex-3-review/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/amazfit-t-rex-3-review/#respond Fri, 01 Nov 2024 14:33:34 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/?p=20727 At IFA 2024, Amazfit unveiled the T-Rex 3, the latest iteration of its rugged outdoor smartwatch. In this review, I will dive into all the watch’s new features, highlighting both its strengths and areas for improvement. If there is one brand that has made a name for itself in recent years, it is Amazfit. And

Der Beitrag Amazfit T-Rex 3 review: A Fenix challenger for a fraction of the price erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
At IFA 2024, Amazfit unveiled the T-Rex 3, the latest iteration of its rugged outdoor smartwatch. In this review, I will dive into all the watch’s new features, highlighting both its strengths and areas for improvement.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 – Packaging

Amazfit T-Rex 3 – Packaging

If there is one brand that has made a name for itself in recent years, it is Amazfit. And rightly so, as Zepp (the company behind the Amazfit brand) mostly produces smartwatches that can usually qualified as very strong value-for-money. Models from Amazfit are available for a fraction of what you would pay for similar devices from Garmin and most of the time, the functional differences are minimal.

As both companies offer an extensive range of models, it is quite difficult to decide on a particular one. Hopefully, this review will help to simplify that procedure as well.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 Overview

Let’s start with giving some context: The T-Rex 3 is the latest generation of Amazfit’s T-Rex series. Some time has passed since the release of its predecessor in may 2022, so the following table compares the key specifications of the T-Rex 3 against the T-Rex 2 and its competition:

T-Rex 3 Grit X2 Pro fenix 8 - 51 mm Race
Display AMOLED AMOLED AMOLED AMOLED
Display size 1.50" 1.39" 1.40" 1.43"
Protection Gorilla Glas Sapphire Glas Gorilla Glas Sapphire Glas
Resolution | PPI 480 × 480 | 320 454 × 454 | 327 454 × 454 | 324 466 × 466 | 326
Dimensions 48.5 × 48.5 × 13.7 mm 48.6 × 48.6 × 13.4 mm 51.0 × 51.0 × 14.7 mm 49.0 × 49.0 × 13.3 mm
Weight 68 g with strap 57 g without strap 74 g without strap 83 g with strap
Material (bezel) Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Stainless Steel
Material (case) Plastic (no further details provided) Stainless Steel Fiber-reinforced polymer Fiber-reinforced polymer

In terms of the very basic specs, the products are quite similar. The T-Rex 3 stands out primarily for its 1.5″ AMOLED display. With a resolution of 480 x 480 pixels, the display boasts a pixel density of 320 PPI, making it comparable to other smartwatches. It delivers content as sharply as Garmin, Suunto, and Polar watches, while benefiting from a slightly larger diameter.

New and Noteworthy

Before we dive into the details of the T-Rex 3, here are the watch’s key new features:

  • 1.5″ AMOLED display
  • Max. 2,000 nits brightness
  • Stainless steel bezel
  • Longer battery life
  • Readiness score
  • Heart rate variability
  • 177+ sports modes
  • Offline maps (including contour and ski maps)
  • Turn-by-turn navigation
  • GPS privacy settings
  • AI integration / microphone + voice control
  • 26 GB storage
  • Contactless payment / NFC
  • Suitable for free diving

As a reminder, the T-Rex 2 was released in May 2022. Therefore, while all the features mentioned here are new to the T-Rex series, they may not be entirely brand-new. Many of these features were introduced in other products and are now also included in the T-Rex 3.

Unboxing and First Impressions

For me, unboxing a new watch is still one of the most exciting moments. However, since Amazfit rarely changes the packaging and presentation of its watches, opening the white T-Rex 3 box has been relatively straightforward.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 in the open box

Amazfit T-Rex 3 in the open box

Inside the box, the T-Rex 3 is displayed first, with a protective film over the display to guard against scratches. In my opinion, this isn’t necessary, as the watch sits securely in its box.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 with protective film

Amazfit T-Rex 3 with protective film

The protective film is the only piece of plastic that needs to be disposed of. Most companies now avoid using cable ties and plastic bags, which is in line with modern sustainability efforts and a positive step forward.

Alongside the watch, there’s also a small USB charging cradle, adapters for standard straps, and a tiny screwdriver in the box.

Accessories and quick guide

Accessories and quick guide

Regarding the USB charging cradle: only the cradle itself is included in the package. Amazfit has opted not to include the cable, which is typically provided with the similar Amazfit Balance charger.

So how does the power get from the adapter to the watch? Via a USB-C cable that plugs into the side port of the charging cradle, which you’ll need to provide yourself. Given the number of USB cables in most households, this shouldn’t be an issue.

The small magnet that is supposed to hold the charging cradle in place during charging could be a bit stronger. It tends to slip more than the Balance charger, likely due to the rigid band of the T-Rex 3 that angles away from the watch case at around 60 degrees.

If you want to swap the strap, you’ll need to attach the included adapters first. After that, you can use standard 22 mm bands with spring bars.

The watch itself stands out with its 1.5″ display and octagonal-round bezel. Octagonal-round doesn’t make sense? Actually, it does. The outer shape of the bezel is octagonal, while the inner form is round to frame the equally round display.

Octagonal-round bezel of the T-Rex 3

Octagonal-round bezel of the T-Rex 3

The stainless steel bezel gives it a more premium look than the T-Rex 2. The build quality is high as usual, with no reason for criticism.

The slightly higher weight of the T-Rex 3 is noticeable, especially when switching from the Polar Vantage V3, which I had been wearing for the past few weeks. There’s no question that the target audiences of both watches differ, and like most outdoor watches, the design and weight of the T-Rex 3 are more prominent. While it was noticeable at first, I can confirm that it isn’t distracting at all, even during movement-intensive activities.

Visually prominent appearance

Visually prominent appearance

In addition to its weight, the T-Rex 3 also stands out visually. A slim profile and narrow bezels aren’t a priority here, which puts the watch in good company with models like the Polar Grit X2 Pro, Suunto Vertical, or Fenix 8.

Amazfit T-Rex 3: Basics

The T-Rex 3 is primarily operated via the touch display and the four buttons, which are evenly distributed on both sides of the watch’s case.

4-Button Design

4-Button Design

The buttons on the left side are used to switch between views and functions, while the buttons on the right side are for selecting and confirming functions, or going back to the previous menu.

Standard Watchface

Standard Watchface

Starting from the watchface, you can navigate through the widgets using the up and down buttons. These widgets are similar to Garmin’s Widget Glances, offering an overview of key metrics or functions. By tapping or pressing the Select button, more detailed information can be accessed.

Widgets on the T-Rex 3 Detailed view of today's steps

You can achieve the same result by pressing the lower right button from the watchface, which opens the main menu, allowing you to access all functions and metrics.

Function menu with all T-Rex 3 features

Function menu with all T-Rex 3 features

Pressing the back button generally returns you to the previous view.

Thanks to the T-Rex 3’s touch-enabled screen, it can be controlled very easily by touch. It is also very responsive, so there are no delays when changing views.

However, there are sometimes functions that can only be accessed by tapping the touchscreen, as no buttons are assigned to these functions.

Generally, that is no problem and the glass seems to have an anti-fingerprint coating.

Features of the Amazfit T-Rex 3

Whenever I evaluate sports watches or smartwatches, I find it helpful to break down their features into these categories:

  • Features adressing everyday life
  • Features adressing health
  • Features adressing sports

I will follow this same structure in this review. But first, let’s start with a look at the nearly fully revamped app. Let’s dive in…

Zepp Health App with New Design

In September, Zepp invited Amazfit Balance owners to participate in the beta program for the revamped version of the Zepp Health App. The app has now been released in its final version and is available on Google’s Play Store and Apple’s App Store.

Dashboard of the Zepp Health App Dashboard of the Zepp Health App Dashboard of the Zepp Health App

The dashboard continues to be the main entry point, featuring the three core aspects — Sleep, Readiness, and Effort — as well as a range of metrics for the current or previous day. The use of tiles has been significantly reduced, which I find makes the layout clearer. Metrics can be shown or hidden based on your individual preferences.

It’s easy to switch views to get detailed information on sleep, readiness, or effort.

Readiness metrics in the dashboard Readiness metrics in the dashboard Effort metrics in the dashboard Effort metrics in the dashboard Sleep metrics in the dashboard Sleep metrics in the dashboard Sleep metrics in the dashboard Sleep metrics in the dashboard

The app largely retains the settings, watch face selection, and app store for connected watches.

The app store still lacks truly standout options. While the selection is growing, nothing has really caught my attention yet.

The watch face selection, however, offers numerous free and now also paid watch faces.

Features adressing everyday life

Each model in Amazfit’s portfolio targets a specific user group. Despite these differences, Amazfit smartwatches are generally quite similar, offering a wide range of features adressing everyday life. This holds true for the T-Rex 3, much like the Amazfit Balance.

Voice Control and Zepp Flow

Not entirely new, but new to the T-Rex series, is the integration of Zepp Flow, which allows for voice control of the watch. Thanks to generative AI, this feature works without predefined keywords, enabling commands in natural language.

Zepp Flow – Textual response to spoken question

Zepp Flow – Textual response to spoken question

In my experience, this works remarkably well. The cool part is that not only can you control watch functions, but also ask general questions (e.g., “How many bridge days are there in April 2025?”) and get answers directly on the watch.

However, there are two minor limitations:

  • For more complex voice commands, a paired smartphone needs to be nearby. A limited number of commands (e.g., Start + Workout Name, Open Music) work in Chinese, English, German, and Spanish without smartphone assistance.
  • Without paired headphones, responses are shown only in text form as the T-Rex 3 lacks a speaker.

Ultimately, it is up to each user to decide when and where to use Zepp Flow. For instance, I’d find it difficult to speak to my watch in a public setting like on public transportation. Nonetheless, it is a feature with great potential that can be further explored over time.

Contactless Payment

Also new to the T-Rex line is contactless payment via NFC, which Amazfit calls Zepp Pay. Amazfit has taken two approaches here:

  • Direct integration

    For direct integration, Amazfit faces the same challenges as many other companies: the number of banks is limited, with major banks not yet supported. Currently, Zepp Pay only supports Mastercard, so Visa or debit cards are not supported.

  • Integration via Curve

    A simpler option, independent of one’s primary bank, is to link through Curve’s virtual credit card, which is fully compatible with Amazfit. Transactions are charged to the cards and accounts linked in the Curve app.

Music: Storage and Playback

Amazfit has offered the ability to store and play MP3 files for quite some time. This feature is also available on the T-Rex 3.

Unfortunately and in my opinion, this feature continues to be somewhat underused for several reasons:

  • Lack of support for streaming services

    In an age where streaming services provide the main access to music, I sorely miss support for popular services like Spotify, Amazon Prime Music, or YouTube Music.

  • Complicated Data Transfer

    This leaves users with no choice but to transfer the music as MP3 files first to the smartphone and then to the watch via the Zepp App. Setting up a private Wi-Fi connection between the watch and the app is tricky, as the smartphone repeatedly chooses the “better” Wi-Fi network with internet access, ending the MP3 upload.

    Only disabling the automatic connection to the home network achieves the desired result.

  • Lack of Organization Features

    Once the music is on the watch, there are no options for organizing the content. Neither directories nor playlists can be created. The two predefined playlists, “Favorites” and “Jogging Music,” show that the functionality is available in principle but is very limited in its use through the watch and app.

    Music on the T-Rex 3: Essentially only two playlists

    Music on the T-Rex 3: Essentially only two playlists

This feature could be greatly improved if the app displayed the content on the watch and allowed users to create folders and playlists directly within the app.

As it stands, the functionality feels like a ‘halfway solution.’ However, the fact that handling MP3 files could be enhanced with just an app update offers hope.

Night Mode in Red, Orange or Green

Amazfit seems to have taken a cue from the competition, equipping the T-Rex 3 with a night mode that tints the display in red, orange or green hues. While this might seem like a gimmick, I find it incredibly useful because, at night, the display is much more eye- and relationship-friendly compared to the brighter, untinted modes.

Night mode display: Red Shift mode

Night mode display: Red Shift mode

Night view: Orange

[ftt_img] [ftt_img src="/wp-content/img/test/amazfit-t-rex-3/amazfit-trex-3-night-mode-green.jpg" width="450" title="Night view: Green"]

Other Features for Everyday Use

In addition to the aforementioned features, the T-Rex 3 also offers several other everyday functions that have become standard features for smartwatches. I will not go into detail about them here, as they are well-known.

Weather App: Forecast Barometer Compass
  • Compass
  • Barometer
  • Weather
  • Alarm
  • Calendar
  • Membership Cards
  • Sunrise/Sunset & Tides
  • Cycle Tracking
  • Stopwatch/Countdown
  • Tasks
  • Voice Memos
  • World Clock
  • Pomodoro Timer

Features addressing health

The Amazfit T-Rex 3 is not only a rugged smartwatch but also offers a range of features designed to provide insights into health and well-being. These include metrics like the Readiness Score, heart rate variability, and PAI (Personal Activity Intelligence). These functions aim to help plan activities, monitor personal health, and support daily decisions that promote long-term well-being.

Readiness Score

Since the summer of last year, Amazfit has been offering the Readiness Score metric on various watches. This metric evaluates different aspects of recovery from the previous night and summarizes them into a score between 0 and 100. The score is meant to reflect how ready you are for upcoming activities.

Readiness Score
Sub-aspects of the Readiness Score Sub-aspects of the Readiness Score Sub-aspects of the Readiness Score

The Readiness Score is generally a useful function to get a quick overview of your current recovery state. I find it helpful that Amazfit provides insights into the different aspects contributing to the overall score.

There are even more detailed insights available in the app. For those interested, additional background information on the individual aspects can be found here.

Readiness Metrics on the Dashboard Readiness Metrics on the Dashboard Physical Recovery Metrics Resting Heart Rate

I am somewhat critical of the often high overall score, even when my sleep or recovery has been suboptimal. Scores above 80 are common, but not every day feels like an “80.” I hope that over time, Amazfit will refine this and make the scores fluctuate more clearly.

Heart Rate Variability

Heart rate variability (HRV) measures the fluctuations in the time span between successive heartbeats and is an important indicator of overall health and stress levels. A high HRV suggests that the body is well able to adapt to different stresses, while a low HRV may indicate stress or exhaustion.

Average Heart Rate Variability from Last Night
Heart Rate Variability Trend from the Last Night Heart Rate Variability Trend from the Past Days

The Amazfit T-Rex 3 continuously monitors HRV at night and provides valuable insights into the autonomic nervous system. HRV analysis helps to better understand how well the body recovers from physical exertion or psychological stress. Especially useful is that HRV data is integrated into various functions like the Readiness Score, providing a more comprehensive view of recovery and readiness for performance. This makes heart rate variability a useful tool for optimizing health in the long run and better managing training and recovery.

PAI – Personal Activity Intelligence

PAI (or: Personal Activity Intelligence) is a fitness metric system based on heart rate and aims to promote long-term health. Rather than focusing solely on steps or calories, PAI calculates the heart rate load during various activities and derives a score from it. The higher and longer the effort, the more points you get. The goal is to consistently achieve a PAI score of 100 or higher to reduce the risk of cardiovascular diseases in the long term.

The first points are easy to earn. The higher the score, the harder it becomes to reach high points, which helps keep motivation high. Points from activities expire after seven days.

PAI: Gain Today
PAI: Trend Over the Last Few Days PAI: Heart Rate Trend

I had to get used to PAI after many manufacturers used different metrics as the central tool for an active lifestyle. What I like is that Amazfit doesn’t only consider intense sports sessions but also moderate activities (e.g., brisk walking, hiking) and sometimes even everyday movements. This makes the design of an active day very flexible and more motivating than if a step goal is always looming on the horizon.

PAI on the Zepp App Dashboard PAI: Reward for Reaching a Goal PAI: Development of the Past Few Days

However, there is criticism: if a 10-km walk does not raise the heart rate enough, this activity will not contribute to the increase of the PAI score—even if the movement itself should have been beneficial to health.

Features addressing sports

With Amazfit watches, there is always a debate about whether they are sporty smartwatches or smart sport watches. I believe the truth lies somewhere in the middle. In any case, the range of features adressing sports is extensive.

New features of the T-Rex 3 include:

  • Offline Maps

    For those exploring unfamiliar terrain, the T-Rex 3’s offline maps will be a valuable feature. To use them, you must first select the desired map section in the app and transfer it to the watch.

    Map management in settings Min. zoom level Max. zoom level

    This works flawlessly and, depending on the size of the map section, quite quickly as well. To transfer the map data to the watch, it must be connected to a Wi-Fi network.

    Two limitations should be considered:

    • Only one map section at a time can be stored on the watch
    • Maximum dimensions: 400 x 675 km

    The fact that only one map section can be stored on the watch isn’t a major issue for me, but for those traveling frequently across multiple countries and unable to swap out map sections, Garmin and Polar might offer more suitable alternatives.

    Preview of the route Preview of the elevation profile

    While the level of detail in cities is quite good, I missed a bit more topographical information in the mountains. The hiking trails were all present, and the contour maps did their job, but a little more geographical detail about the surroundings would have been even better.

  • Navigation

    Offline maps are already a fantastic feature, but they become even more valuable when paired with the route and navigation capabilities of the T-Rex 3.

    Routes can be imported either as GPX files or by linking the watch to Komoot. However, integration with Strava for route import is still not supported.

    Linking with external services Linking with Komoot Importing routes from Komoot

    Before starting an activity (e.g., outdoor running, hiking), a route can be selected for use. For the route, you can:

    • View a route profile
    • View an elevation profile
    • Get information on ski slopes
    • Set the map orientation (map always points north vs. map points in the direction of movement)
    • Set the route direction (from A to B or from B to A)

    How the T-Rex 3 gathers information about ski slopes remains a bit of a mystery. Despite the lack of nearby ski areas, the watch still provides slope information. It seems that Amazfit may determine downhill tracks based on longer, downward sections of the route. However, the slope data is limited to an elevation profile rather than a map representation.

    Map display with a white background Map display with a dark background

    During the activity, the map is displayed in the light variant with a white background or in the dark variant with a black background. The colors of the route and the traveled distance can be adjusted in the watch settings (default: Magenta and Blue).

    Tracking a route on the T-Rex 3

    Tracking a route on the T-Rex 3

    If you deviate from the route, the T-Rex 3 will alert you. However, since the watch doesn’t offer pathfinding, there’s no option to recalculate the way back to the planned route. That said, with the watch warning you after a deviation of just 50 meters, the risk of getting lost is minimal. You can also adjust the maximum deviation setting to trigger earlier or later warnings, depending on your preference.

    Warning when deviating from the route

    Warning when deviating from the route

    Notification when returning to the route

    Notification when returning to the route

    The watch also acknowledges when you return to the original route.

    The distance from the planned route at which the T-Rex 3 warns you can be reduced to 20 meters, or increased if necessary.

    When following a route, if a direction change is required, the T-Rex 3 shows the distance to the next turn. Just before the change (e.g., at a junction or fork), the watch reminds you again.

    Displaying the distance to the next direction change

    Displaying the distance to the next direction change

    This has worked very well so far, although you have to get used to the fact that sometimes your position is shown slightly off the road: the map material simply does not know the width of roads, so even a road with a green strip in the middle is represented with the same line as a one-lane side street. If there is also a green strip between the road and the sidewalk, your current position may appear a little off the displayed road.

    Amazfit can tick off the “Offline Maps and Navigation” feature, although there is still some room for improvement: Currently, only Garmin provides map material that can be used for route finding. For Amazfit, Polar, and others, the maps are no more (but also no less) than images projected onto the current location.

  • Diving

    I unfortunately can’t contribute any personal experience with freediving to this review. However, it should be noted that the T-Rex 3 is certified for dives up to 45 meters deep.

    It apparently measures the current and maximum dive depth, dive time, and ascent speed. However, essential metrics for a real dive computer are missing, such as No-Decompression Limits (NDL), decompression stops, and surface intervals.

Before Recording

Before starting a sports activity, you select the appropriate sport from the sports menu.

Selection of the sport

Selection of the sport

Then, for outdoor activities, the T-Rex 3 searches for a GNSS signal. Like most Amazfit models, it is one of the faster ones. A satellite fix is found within seconds.

Waiting for all signals

Waiting for all signals

At this point, you can not only wait for signals from satellites and external sensors (e.g., Bluetooth heart rate straps) but also adjust settings for the upcoming recording, such as selecting routes, intervals, and workouts. You also have the option to configure the data pages and fields for display during recording: The T-Rex 3 allows up to 6 data fields per data page.

After Recording

After completing the recording, the watch briefly summarizes the sporting aspects.

Past recordings Summary

You can browse through a variety of details and charts that essentially display the values that can also be found in the app after synchronization.

Training Effect Values HR Zones

The T-Rex 3 benefits once again from its high-resolution 1.5″ display.

Chart: Heart Rate Chart: Power Chart: Pace

In the app, the data is, of course, even more clearly displayed:

Details of a sporting activity recording in the app Details of a sporting activity recording in the app Details of a sporting activity recording in the app Details of a sporting activity recording in the app Details of a sporting activity recording in the app Details of a sporting activity recording in the app

The app has a clean and organized interface, and many of the metrics it provides are comparable to those found in Garmin devices. However, especially for power measurement and training effects, the results may differ, as each company uses its own algorithms for these calculations.

Accuracy of location tracking

For many, the quality of a sports watch largely depends on the accuracy of its GPS, or more broadly, its GNSS capabilities. The T-Rex 3 supports not only dual-band GPS but also GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou, and QZSS. This is an important feature, as accurate location tracking becomes crucial when venturing off familiar paths.

While there are no mountains, canyons, or other challenging conditions in the suburban areas around Berlin, I tested the watch on familiar routes, both with and without tree cover, through areas with terraced houses and narrow streets to see how well it performed.

What stood out was how effortlessly the T-Rex 3 handled these conditions. There was no reason to complain about its performance, and even the short section through the forest was navigated without issue.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of location tracking

From a high vantage point, it becomes clear that the GNSS chip and antenna design of the T-Rex 3 do their job seamlessly.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of location tracking Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of location tracking

Only when looking closely do you see some deviations that both Amazfit models share. However, there is nothing significant, and regardless of which products you use, you will occasionally notice slight offsets from the actual path.

ProductDistancePace
Amazfit T-Rex 35.06 km7'20"
Amazfit Cheetah Pro5.03 km7'23"
Coros Pace 35.10 km7'18"
Polar Vantage V35.09 km7'19"

In the end, I consider the deviations to be negligible.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of location tracking Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of location tracking Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of location tracking

In the next test, there was again a high level of agreement with the competition, though some deviations appeared upon closer inspection. This is not uncommon right after the start of the recording, when, although sufficient satellite signals are available for an initial location fix, a greater number of GNSS signals would improve the reliability of the positioning.

Accuracy of Heart Rate Monitoring

As always, I not only looked at the accuracy of the GPS tracking but also checked how accurately the T-Rex 3 measures the heart rate.

As a reference, I used the Polar H10 chest strap, with which I have always had excellent experiences, and by which most products are evaluated.

I’m not sure if it is obvious from the curves, but the effects of my COVID infection from early September still make my body feel strained during exercise. What’s important is how the T-Rex 3 compares to the Polar H10 and how it holds up against the competition.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of heart rate measurement Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of heart rate measurement

During a run with some intervals, surprisingly, it is the heart rate chest strap that seems to have issues. If I had to guess the reason today, I would suspect too dry skin or contact issues with the chest strap. However, I can’t say for sure. Since the Polar H10 remains a stable measuring instrument, I excluded the initial anomalies for further analysis.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of heart rate measurement

The difference chart highlights the solid performance of the T-Rex 3, although it falls behind during intervals and doesn’t always capture rapid heart rate spikes accurately.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of heart rate measurement Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of heart rate measurement Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Accuracy of heart rate measurement

This is reflected in the coefficient of determination (r²), which indicates how well the values from one or the other sport watch matches the heart rate chest strap, which serves as the reference here.

The T-Rex 3 can’t quite top the comparison and has to let the Coros Pace 3 take the lead. However, it still performs better than the Amazfit Cheetah Pro, which was even less accurate in tracking heart rate during the intervals.

With fewer pace changes, the T-Rex 3 consistently provided reliable and comparable values. During rapid changes in heart rate, it faces the same challenges as many competitors and therefore doesn’t stand out either positively or negatively.

Battery Life

On paper, the T-Rex 3 stands out as a true battery life champion. However, confirming or disproving this through user testing is still challenging for me, even after nearly 10 years of testing sports watches.

Company-provided specifications are typically based on controlled environments, so they serve as a general indication rather than an absolute benchmark for real-world usage. Even small changes, such as additional screen activations or adjusting the brightness, can cause these numbers to vary.

As mentioned, the T-Rex 3 impresses on paper, and the great news is that it performs just as well in everyday use. I managed to get through the first three weeks without a charge, although my sports activity was minimal. It was only when the battery dropped to 8% that I needed to recharge.

In the following weeks, the T-Rex 3 had to record activities more frequently. This not only draws more power due to the active GNSS, but the PPG sensor also works at a second-by-second rate.

What does this mean in the end? The battery life specs seem plausible, although I cannot fully validated them due to varying usage. Is this important? No, because the T-Rex 3 offers an impressive battery life regardless and is quickly recharged for the next use.

Amazfit T-Rex 3 - Verdict

Rating: 93%
Score: 93%
Pros
  • Great 1.5" AMOLED display
  • Offline maps / navigation
  • Extensive metrics
  • Battery life
  • Value-for-money ratio
Cons
  • limited support to Zepp Pay
  • Music upload / playlists
  • Apps

The Amazfit T-Rex 3 is a successful blend of a rugged outdoor smartwatch and a smart health companion. Its impressive value-for-money ratio stands out: it offers a wide range of fitness metrics, including Readiness Score, PAI, and HRV analysis, supporting an active and health-focused lifestyle. Outdoor enthusiasts will especially appreciate the offline maps and GNSS support, which provide reliable navigation in various terrains.

Another standout feature is the battery life; even with intensive use, it lasts exceptionally long, making it an attractive option for frequent users and adventurers. The solid build quality, excellent 1.5″ AMOLED display, and intuitive app complete the overall package.

While the T-Rex 3 may not match the Fenix 8 in app variety, advanced mapping features, music functionality, or premium material quality, it certainly holds its own as a competitor. For those unwilling to pay three to four times the price, the T-Rex 3 stands out as an excellent alternative.

Disclosure: The Amazfit T-Rex 3 to me by Zepp, free of charge, at my request for testing. No conditions were attached to this review, and the opinions and experiences shared here reflect my entirely unbiased assessment of the product.

Der Beitrag Amazfit T-Rex 3 review: A Fenix challenger for a fraction of the price erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/amazfit-t-rex-3-review/feed/ 0
Garmin Forerunner 165 Review: Budget, still feature-packed https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/garmin-forerunner-165-review/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/garmin-forerunner-165-review/#respond Tue, 23 Jul 2024 19:36:04 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/?p=20456 Compact yet packed with features for running, the Forerunner 165 delivers exceptional value at an affordable price. I examined it closely in my review.

Der Beitrag Garmin Forerunner 165 Review: Budget, still feature-packed erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
If you’re on the hunt for a top-notch sports watch, Garmin’s offerings are hard to overlook. Among them, the Forerunner 165 stands out with its impressive blend of lightweight design and a comprehensive suite of features. Having extensively reviewed this model, I can attest to its blend of practicality and performance.

With the Forerunner 165, Garmin introduced a watch that not only broadened the existing lineup but also established a new category within the Forerunner series. Positioned strategically between the entry-level Forerunner 55 and the mid-range Forerunner 265, the Forerunner 165 bridges the gap between basic and advanced features.

Garmin Forerunner 165 - Display at startup

Garmin provided me with the Forerunner 165 for a 60-day testing period upon my request. As always, there are no conditions or obligations attached. And because it is a loan, the watch will return to Garmin after the testing period.

Wertung: 92%
Rating: 92%
Pros
  • great display
  • feature-packed
Cons
  • no multisport / triathlon
  • no training load / training readiness
  • lots of plastic

Verdict

The Garmin Forerunner 165 is dedicated to running and offers most of its functions in this area but is equally suitable for many other sports. I was impressed by the great display and the mix of functions that the watch inherited from significantly more expensive models. The Forerunner 165 leaves little to be desired, but the decision for the watch is not an easy one.

There are good alternatives from Garmin and competitors – Garmin has not really occupied a niche with the Forerunner 165. Yet, it is the overall package that makes the Forerunner so attractive for entry into Garmin’s sports segment.

Forerunner 165 – What’s new and noteworthy?

Typically, watches within a product line evolve incrementally from one generation to the next — such as the Forerunner 245 evolving into the Forerunner 255, and then the Forerunner 265. This makes it straightforward to compare successive generations within the same series.

However, with the introduction of a completely new product line, comparing the new model requires a broader perspective. In this case, positioning the Forerunner 165 involves looking at the adjacent models: the more affordable Forerunner 55 and the higher-end Forerunner 265. This approach helps in better understanding the new model’s place within Garmin’s lineup.

  • Distinction from Forerunner 55

    The Forerunner 55, now three years old, is considered quite outdated in the rapidly evolving world of wearables. The difference between the Forerunner 55 and the Forerunner 165 is striking, particularly in their displays. The Forerunner 55 is equipped with a 1.04″ transflective MIP display, whereas the Forerunner 165 boasts a 1.2″ AMOLED touchscreen with a much higher resolution.

    Comparing the features of these two watches would be like comparing day and night. The Forerunner 165 benefits from the latest fourth-generation Elevate sensors, whereas the Forerunner 55 relies on the third generation, underscoring the significant advancements in technology and features.

  • Distinction from Forerunner 265

    Distinguishing the Forerunner 165 from the Forerunner 265, which debuted in March 2023, is more straightforward.

    Starting with the display, Garmin basically uses the same touch-capable AMOLED screen for both models. However, the Forerunner 265 is available in two sizes: 1.1″ and 1.3″, compared to the Forerunner 165’s 1.2″ display.

    Functionally, the Forerunner 165 offers fewer features than the higher-end Forerunner 265. As a buyer of the Forerunner 165, you will need to forgo the following advanced features:

    • Multiband GPS
    • Training Readiness
    • Training Status
    • Training Load
    • Support for Multisport/Triathlon
    • Greater range of sports profiles
    • Sat-IQ
    • Pace adjusted to incline
    • Connection to power meters/smart meters

    The list is by no means exhaustive, but it would get lost in detail. These are the main features that the Forerunner 165 does not offer.

  • Features of the Forerunner 165 at a glance

    When comparing the Forerunner 165 to the Forerunner 265, the list of differences can seem extensive, which might overshadow the fact that for most athletes, the Forerunner 165 is an exceptionally well-rounded sports watch. While it may lack some advanced metrics and features found in the Forerunner 265, these omissions are unlikely to be missed in the initial months or even years of use.

    With this perspective in mind, here’s a concise overview of the key features of the Forerunner 165 before we dive into the details:

    • 1.2″ AMOLED display (touch-capable, hardened glass)
    • 39 g lightweight plastic case with silicone strap
    • Elevate V4 sensor
    • Multi-GNSS (GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, etc.)
    • Garmin Pay
    • Music playback (MP3, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube Music, Deezer)
    • Barometric altimeter

Unboxing and first impression

As is typical with Garmin, the Forerunner 165 comes packaged in a compact gray box, adorned with the product name and an image of the sports watch. This model is offered in a variety of colors including turquoise, berry, white, and black.

Contents of the packaging

There’s nothing particularly surprising about the packaging, so I’ll keep this brief:

  • Garmin Forerunner 165
  • Strap (circumference: 126 – 203 mm)
  • USB charging cable (USB-C to proprietary)
  • Warranty/safety instructions

Garmin has been using the same 4-pin connector for the charging port for years. However, the other end of the cable now features a USB-C connector.

Forerunner 165 with lots of plastic

Overall, the build quality of the Forerunner 165 is good. The extensive use of plastic is typical for the Forerunner series, resulting in a low weight and a somewhat less premium appearance.

Back of the Forerunner 165 Forerunner 165 side view

Case, back, and buttons – everything is made of plastic but is well crafted. Gaps are rare, and when they do exist, they are even and small.

Forerunner 165: A Basic Operation Guide

The Forerunner 165 features the typical 5-button design found on most Garmin sports watches. Two of the three buttons on the left side are primarily for navigating through menus and functions, while the third button manually turns the display on and off.

5-button design of the Forerunner 165

The buttons on the right side of the case allow you to:

  • Start features / activities
  • Stop features / activities
  • Access menu items
  • Go back

At the same time, the Forerunner 165 can be fully operated using the touch display. The choice is yours.

Display of the Forerunner 165

As it is a good fit here, let me briefly share my impressions of the AMOLED display:

Forerunner 165 with activated display

The display offers a 1.2″ size, which is the middle ground between the Forerunner 265S and the Forerunner 265. Initially, I thought a 1.3″ display wouldn’t be bad, but the smaller display looks great on my wrist.

The contrast, colors, and brightness of the display are impressive. Even in direct sunlight, the contents are easily readable.

To ensure the display doesn’t light up the bedroom at night, the watch adjusts the brightness to a lower level. The “night times” can be individually set for each day of the week.

Night time settings Display brightness settings

The watch also includes a flashlight using the display at a bright setting. While not as powerful as those in the Fenix 7 and Epix 2, it is useful for certain purposes.

There are now numerous watch faces (i.e., function-enriched watch dials) available – either pre-installed or downloaded to the watch via Connect IQ.

Pre-installed watch face 1/2 Pre-installed watch face 2/2

From the watch face, you can access the widgets using the up/down buttons or by swiping up/down. These are small, three-line views of individual metrics, such as HRV status, step count or sleep.

Widgets on the Forerunner 165
Widgets on the Forerunner 165 Widgets on the Forerunner 165

By tapping or selecting widgets using the button, you can access the corresponding detailed views. The display showcases its strengths with its high resolution.

Detailed view of daily steps Detailed view of weekly steps Detailed view of weekly steps

The same information that you see on the watch can be found in the Connect app, which Garmin offers for free for iOS and Android.

Functions in Everyday Life

Many of the Forerunner 165’s features come from the higher-end models. Among the newer ones is the HRV status, which the watch determines during sleep. To obtain comparable values, patience is required initially, as the watch needs 19 nights to establish a baseline.

HRV status - Average of the last 7 days

After that, the HRV status is displayed either in a widget or as part of the Morning Report.

Reminder: Heart Rate Variability (HRV) measures the time difference between consecutive heartbeats. Higher HRV values generally indicate better adaptability to stress, as they reflect a more flexible autonomic nervous system. However, this should be interpreted relative to an individual’s baseline. Therefore, a person with an HRV of 65 ms is not necessarily healthier or more resilient than someone with an HRV of 30 ms.

The watch displays the average HRV from the previous night and compares it to the average HRV from the past four weeks.

HRV trend of the last night HRV baseline

This information is also available in the app, which is particularly useful for evaluating data over longer periods.

This brings me to the Morning Report, which, in addition to the HRV status, summarizes the most important values (from the previous day, night, and the upcoming day) in a simple manner.

Morning Report

The watch breaks down sleep into phases and tracks sleep duration. While these metrics provide valuable insights, they are indicative rather than definitive. A professional sleep lab would offer much more precise and comprehensive data. However, in my perception, the sleeping and waking times fit very well.

Sleep evaluation display
Display showing the time distribution of sleep phases Display showing the chronological sequence of sleep phases Display showing sleep stages over the last few days

Once again, the watch provides insights into recent data only, while the app offers summaries on a weekly, monthly, or yearly basis.

Speaking of sleep: as you know, it helps replenish your energy reserves, which Garmin represents as the Body Battery, depleting over the day – especially with high stress and activities.

Body Battery display Nap Detection: Detected nap

But not only nighttime sleep provides new energy; Garmin’s Nap Detection reliably recognizes daytime naps as well.

In the Music variant, the Forerunner 165 allows storing and especially playing music via Bluetooth-connected headphones or speakers. Pairing with headphones from Shokz, Jabra, and Soundcore worked without any issues.

Music playback on the Forerunner 165 Music

Honestly, having the option to enjoy music is a fantastic feature that provides entertainment and distraction from your heavy breathing during sports. Personally, I’m not concerned with whether the Sony Walkman NW-A306 or a similar device sounds significantly better. While the expectations might be different when relaxing at home, on the track, other aspects are more important. I appreciate being able to leave my smartphone at home just for the sake of enjoying music.

Forerunner 165 for Sports

Anyone opting for a Forerunner model generally has sports in focus, and given its price, the Forerunner 165 is easily convincing in this regard.

The sport mode is activated by pressing the upper right button. Numerous sport profiles are available, although the list is more concise compared to Garmin’s higher-priced models or competitors.

Sport mode with selection of sport profiles

In addition to the basic sports, the Forerunner 165 also offers exotic options such as Pickleball and Padel.

Besides simple documentation, a sport profile serves as a set of settings to be applied when selecting the profile.

Data page with one data field Data page with two data fields Data page with three data fields Data page with four data fields

This includes data pages and data fields, with each data page accommodating between 1 to 4 fields. You can display a wide range of current and averaged values, as well as small charts, to suit your needs.

Selection of data fields

A unique feature is the running metrics and running power, which are quite rare for an entry-level watch.

As usual, alarms can also be set up, allowing for targeted training (e.g. by heart rate, pace, or running power).

Speaking of targeted training: in addition to the free training modes, the Forerunner 165 also suggests workouts based on your performance and the load from previous days.

Daily training recommendation

From my experience with running, these recommendations can be valuable at times but also occasionally puzzling: Eight minutes per kilometer is too slow for me, while a pace of 5:30 minutes, even for just 25 minutes, is quite challenging for me.

Since I needed some more custom test data for this report, I politely but firmly ignored the recommendation.

In addition to Garmin’s training suggestions, custom workouts can be stored in Garmin Connect and called up before starting a session. This makes intervals or following a route easily possible.

Intervall-Training Verfolgung einer Route

To give some context: The Forerunner 165 allows you to follow breadcrumb trails, meaning it provides route guidance without referencing or displaying maps. Essentially, you follow a virtual line on the ground.

Routes can be defined in Garmin Connect, as well as on third-party platforms like Komoot, and transferred to the watch. Routes that have been completed but not explicitly defined beforehand can be tracked later as route guidance.

Display during recording

During an activity, you can scroll through data pages using the buttons. This also works with touch gestures, which I prefer to keep disabled.

After recording ends, Garmin automatically synchronizes the Forerunner 165 with the app or cloud, allowing you to review your workout (as well as daily metrics) on your wrist, smartphone, or tablet.

Review of a recording on the watch
Pace review display on the watch Heart rate review display on the watch Heart rate zones review display on the watch Running performance review display on the watch Performance zones review display on the watch Training effect display on the watch

Most of the data is readily available on the watch. For additional information from paired sensors, it’s worthwhile to check the more comprehensive app. Garmin also offers the convenience of accessing this data through the Garmin Connect web portal.

In addition to the very text-heavy analysis on the first screens in the app, the data is also presented more attractively in charts:

To check if the data relates one way or the other, you can overlay various charts.

This allows for some nice composed charts, perfect for showing off to friends and family :)

A step back to sensors: The Forerunner 165 supports pairing with external sensors via Bluetooth and ANT+. Additionally, it can also act as an external sensor itself, transmitting heart rate data via BLE or ANT+ to other devices.

Accuracy in Location Data Determination

With GPS, GLONASS, and Galileo, the Forerunner 165 supports the main satellite systems used for positioning. However, compared to more expensive models, it lacks SatIQ and multiband capability, i.e., simultaneous use of the L1 and L5 frequency bands.

Positioning system settings / GNSS

In challenging environments, such as mountains, areas with dense buildings, or densely wooded forests, some accuracy may be sacrificed because the secondary signal cannot be used to correct timing errors. For most casual runners, multiband GPS is generally not necessary.

Many questions I receive revolve around the fact that multiband GPS does not actually increase GPS accuracy but rather helps reduce errors primarily caused by signal reflection.

Of course, I also took the Forerunner 165 out and compared it with the following sports watches:

  • Polar Ignite 3
  • Amazfit Cheetah Pro
  • Coros Pace 3
  • Forerunner 245

Dense construction is hard to find here, and the Berlin outskirts also lack mountains, but it does offer sections through forests, residential areas, and open fields.

Route recording with the Forerunner 165

From a high-level perspective, all participants’ recordings are quite similar. However, the Polar Ignite 3 follows a noticeably different path, and at times, the Forerunner 245 appears to deviate in a similar manner.

Route recording with the Forerunner 165

And actually, it doesn’t matter where you run with the Forerunner 165; the results always make a good impression, even if you can’t shake the feeling that Garmin smooths the values more than the competition.

But let’s take a closer look at the following run.

Route recording with the Forerunner 165

On closer inspection, it becomes clear that even the Forerunner 165 has its quirks. This means that the watch sometimes positions itself a few meters off the road, not on the sidewalk but in front gardens. This is not a specific problem of sports watches but an issue with GPS accuracy in general.

Route recording with the Forerunner 165

Overall, the results are good to very good, as the new Garmin model shows few outliers and provides consistent performance.

Route recording with the Forerunner 165

Even the section through the now heavily wooded forest is completed without issues by the watch.

Route recording with the Forerunner 165

In my view, the Forerunner 165 performs strongly across all disciplines. There are no significant or consistent outliers in its recordings. When it does deviate, it’s only briefly and is generally on par with much more expensive models.

Accuracy in Heart Rate Recording

Besides route accuracy, no topic triggers people more than the accuracy of heart rate recordings. Here too, the Forerunner 165 had to measure up against models from Polar, Coros, and the Forerunner 245. The Amazfit Cheetah Pro, on the other hand, picked up data from the Polar H10 chest strap, which, despite its age, is one of the most accurate and reliable sensors available. For this reason, I like to use it as a reference for determining r².

Let’s look at a few runs with warm-up, intervals, and cool-down.

Comparison of heart rate recording

And as if the H10 chest strap wanted to disprove me, it has a dropout right at the beginning of the recording. Strap shifting or contacts not wet enough – it’s hard to say today. After a few minutes, the chest strap got back on track.

The sports watches, however, are all quite close to each other. When looking at the difference from the chest strap and ignoring the initial outlier, you see a typical shift along the time axis, i.e., the watch’s PPG sensor is a bit slower in detecting heart rate changes.

Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording

Interestingly, the Forerunner 245 with the older third-generation Elevate sensor provides nearly identical values compared to the fourth-generation Elevate sensor.

Comparison of heart rate recording

How close the values of the chest strap and the sports watches are is shown by the coefficient of determination r². The closer the value is to 1, the better the sports watches “follow” the chest strap.

Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording

Due to the slower response, the Forerunner 165 lags behind the other sports watches with a value of 0.905. The Coros Pace 3 matches the chest strap’s values best. But these are only gradual differences.

Comparison of heart rate recording

On the next run, the Forerunner 165’s slower response reappears during the intervals, showing the first signs of this issue once again.

Comparison of heart rate recording

Here too, it’s clear how similar the two generations of Elevate technology are. The Forerunner 165 takes longer to detect rapid heart rate changes during intervals.

Comparison of heart rate recording

The older technology of the Forerunner 245 is often closer to the values of the HR chest strap.

Comparison of heart rate recording
Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording Comparison of heart rate recording

As with the previous run, the Forerunner 165 ranks last in the comparison of coefficients of determination with a value of 0.941. The Coros Pace 3 emerges as the performance leader once again with a coefficient of 0.984. However, these are minor differences, and all watches deliver solid results.

In scenarios with steady heart rates, such as during a regular run, all models perform similarly, with no significant outliers observed in the Forerunner 165 or any other models.

In summary, the performance of the Forerunner 165 is commendable, ranging from good to very good.

Comfort

After 60 days of testing, I can also comment on comfort. It’s quite good: The watch is light, compact, and unobtrusive in daily life.

The strap has caused me some issues, and I can’t pinpoint exactly why: The narrow 18-mm silicone strap has caused skin irritations much more often than, for example, the wide strap of a Polar Vantage V3 (Review | German).

Forerunner 165 on wrist Forerunner 165 on wrist

My skin under the strap was much more frequently moist, and the strap rubbed despite a normal fit. After just three weeks, I had to keep switching the Forerunner 165 between my left and right wrist to give each wrist time to recover. In the end, both wrists were significantly marked.

Experiences from other users show, however, that this is not a general problem with the Forerunner watch or Garmin. It’s my personal issue with narrow silicone straps. If you find yourself in a similar situation, I strongly recommend nylon bands, which are also available in the right sizes for the Forerunner 165. This will eliminate the problems almost instantly.

Battery Life

I always hesitate to evaluate battery life in detail. It depends on so many factors (e.g., always-on use, number of display activations, display brightness, power-off time, GNSS systems, music playback, etc.) that it’s unlikely to find two identical scenarios.

When used as a smartwatch with gesture-based display activation, it easily lasts a full week. Garmin states the battery life as up to 11 days. Since a weekend is always a regular occasion to charge the watch, I usually do it every seven days.

A completely empty battery takes about 100 minutes to fully charge. After that, it provides enough power for many hours of recording, even when using multiple GNSS systems.

For those who want to know exactly, you can try to get an impression from Garmin’s breakdown.

Garmin Forerunner 165 - Verdict

Rating: 92%
Score: 92%
Pros
  • great display
  • feature-packed
Cons
  • no multisport / triathlon
  • no training load / training readiness
  • lots of plastic

After 60 days of testing, the Forerunner 165 proves to be an exceptionally well-equipped sports watch. Especially beginner runners and even ambitious runners will not miss any features if running is the focus. Even those who increase their expectations over time will find the Forerunner 165 to be a good training partner. However, the possibilities for structured training planning, taking into account training load and recovery, are reserved for the higher-end models.

Although Garmin focuses the watch on running sports, it is also a great companion for many other sports. It just offers a larger range of features specifically for running.

With the AMOLED display, touch control, and also button control, Garmin combines what I believe to be the best approaches for using the watch. The two buttons on the otherwise quite similar vivoactive 5 almost feel a bit limiting in comparison.

The biggest challenge for the watch will likely come from the competition. For its price and the functions it offers for everyday use, there are few alternatives. However, those who don’t need the ultimate all-rounder will find numerous and sometimes more affordable options. Models such as the Coros Pace 3, Polar Ignite 3 or Pacer Pro, and the Amazfit Cheetah Pro are also highly recommended and can be significantly cheaper.

Disclosure: The Forerunner 165 to me by Garmin, free of charge, at my request for testing. No conditions were attached to this review, and the opinions and experiences shared here reflect my entirely unbiased assessment of the product.

Der Beitrag Garmin Forerunner 165 Review: Budget, still feature-packed erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/garmin-forerunner-165-review/feed/ 0
Coros Pace 3 Review – Great value for money https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/coros-pace-3-review/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/coros-pace-3-review/#respond Sun, 05 May 2024 13:25:59 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/?p=20032 The Coros Pace 3 is arguably the best sports watch you can buy for a budget-friendly price. I had the opportunity to test it out.

Der Beitrag Coros Pace 3 Review – Great value for money erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
The Coros Pace 3 does sport many useful features at an attractive price. I’ve had the opportunity to test the sports watch for weeks and can share my experiences with you here.

Coros Pace 3 held in hand

Coros Pace 3 in profile

Wertung: 88%
Rating: 88%
Pros
  • numerous sports functions
  • fast multi-band GPS
  • great value for money
Cons
  • slow USB data transfer
  • lots of plastic

Verdict

In my opinion, the Coros Pace 3 is currently the sports watch when it comes to value for money. I was particularly impressed by its long battery life, ease of use and extensive range of functions. The low weight makes the watch largely forgettable in everyday life – also because it keeps a low profile when it comes to smart features.

The simple choice of materials and the slow transfer of MP3 files are minor shortcomings of the watch but do not detract from the great product.

Coros is one of the lesser-known brands, especially on the European market. Wrongly so, as the company offers a range of sports watches that can easily compete with Garmin and Polar.

Coros offers entry-level models in the Pace series, while the current Vertix models cover the other end of the performance spectrum. In the entry-level segment in particular, Coros has launched a new model, the Coros Pace 3, which in many respects is similar to its predecessor, the Pace 2, but still offers a range of new features.

Coros Pace 3 vs. Pace 2 – What’s New?

Coros launched the Pace 2 in August 2020. It’s therefore not surprising that the Pace 3 does offer many new features:

  • Multiband GPS

    Coros was one of the first companies to incorporate multi-band GPS into its watches. Meanwhile, the more robust method of positioning is not only found in the premium models but is also offered by the Pace 3.

  • PPG Sensor with SpO2 Measurement

    A new feature is the enhanced PPG sensor on the back, which has 5 LEDs and four photodiodes. Compared to the Pace 2, the Pace 3 also offers SpO2 (peripheral oxygen saturation) measurement.

  • HRV Tracking

    The measurement of heart rate variability (HRV) can also be attributed to the new PPG sensor. HRV is measured during the night and indicates physical stress deviations from the average values (e.g. due to exercise or illness).

  • Touchscreen

    The 1.2-inch display of the Pace 3 has not increased in size or resolution compared to the Pace 2, but it does respond to tapping and swiping gestures.

  • Music Storage and Playback

    The Pace 3 allows MP3 files to be stored on the watch and played on headphones or loudspeakers via Bluetooth. There is 4 GB of storage space available for this purpose.

  • Wi-Fi

    The new Wi-Fi capabilities of the Pace 3 do not currently benefit the transfer of MP3 files, as they only serve to speed up the installation of firmware updates.

The smaller and more modern technology also improves battery life. More on this later…

Specifications

[ftt_comparison id=’17’]

Package Contents

For those who have been following developments or already own a wearable, it’s no surprise that the contents of most product packaging are relatively predictable.

Opened packaging of the Coros Pace 3 in Red

Coros Pace 3 – Package Contents

The Coros Pace 3 is no exception, and so after opening the box you’ll find:

  • Coros Pace 3 sports watch
  • 2x spare spring bars
  • USB charging cable
  • Safety/warranty information
Spare parts for the Coros Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Spare Spring Bars

Coros largely dispenses with plastic, only the protection on the display of the watch is made of plastic.

First Impression

When unpacking the Pace 3, I experienced a deja-vu moment because the Coros Pace 2 and the new Pace 3 are virtually identical.

Coros Pace 2 in Black and Coros Pace 3 in Red side by side

Coros Pace 3 vs. Coros Pace 2

Admittedly, the strap of the Pace 3 is two millimetres wider, the markings on the bezel are different, and the shape of a button on the right-hand side of the case is slightly different, but all in such small dimensions that you have to look for the differences.

Otherwise, as with the Pace 2, the simple design and the simple, but by no means poor construction of the Pace 3 are striking.

The case continues to be made entirely of fiber-reinforced polymer, and the display is protected by chemically hardened glass.

Sensors of the Coros Pace 3 on the back of the watch

Coros Pace 3 – PPG Sensors on the back

This has one decisive advantage, and that is the lower weight. At just 30 grams, the Pace 3 is only one gram heavier than the Pace 2 and is still an absolute lightweight.

Nylon strap with Velcro closures

Coros Pace 3 – Nylon Strap with Velcro Closure

The nylon strap contributes positively to this, but could be 1-2 cm longer to fit comfortably over large hands. It definitely shouldn’t be shorter for me.

Speaking of the strap: the Coros Pace 3 is available with a silicone or nylon strap. If you want to do something good for your skin, I really recommend the textile nylon strap, as it leads to significantly less skin irritation when the watch is worn constantly.

Display

The Pace 3 is still equipped with a 1.2″ transflective MIP display. It has a resolution of 240 x 240 pixels and can only display 64 colors, but it is extremely energy-efficient.

Because the display can do without a backlight in most situations, the watch’s battery can last up to 17 days with the display always on.

The display technology used has its advantages and disadvantages:

Advantages

  • Always-On feature
  • Energy-efficient
  • High contrast in bright ambient light (e.g., direct sunlight)

Disadvantages

  • Lower resolution
  • Limited color representation
  • Low contrast in low ambient light (e.g., at dusk)

Even though AMOLED displays are now found in many sports watches, including the premium segment, I still find the advantages of MIP displays greater during outdoor sports than those of AMOLED displays, which otherwise demonstrate their advantages more clearly in all other situations.

Features

Let’s take a look at the features of the Pace 3, which I’ll divide into common and sports functions as usual. But let’s start with the basics of the Pace 3.

Watchface of the Coros Pace 3 with black background and red accent color

Coros Pace 3 – Watchface

When you look at the watch, it usually displays the watch face. These days it’s more than a dial and most often display the time and several other metrics.

Selection of alternative watchfaces directly on the watch

Coros Pace 3 – Exchange and color design of watchfaces

By the way, Coros has extended the number of different watch faces alot so that there should be something suitable for everyone.

Representation of various watchfaces in the Coros app Representation of various watchfaces in the Coros app Representation of various watchfaces in the Coros app Representation of various watchfaces in the Coros app Representation of various watchfaces in the Coros app Representation of various watchfaces in the Coros app

If you can’t do anything with the watch faces offered, you can create your own watch face via the app.

Starting from the watch face, you can switch to the widgets using the digital crown or swipe gestures. They are somewhat reminiscent of the Garmin widgets and display the daily readings in a short and concise form.

Representation of the Representation of the Representation of the Representation of the

If you tap on a widget, the detailed view opens, in which the metrics are displayed in a little more detail. You can’t really get much out of the display, as in most cases it is a classification of the current day’s values compared to the previous days.

Representation of the HRV status on the Coros Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Widget with HRV status

Current HRV value on the Coros Pace 3 Textual description of the HRV value on the Coros Pace 3 Trend of the HRV value of the last days on the Coros Pace 3

I’ve shown this using the “HRV status” metric.

By swiping right or pressing the button below the digital crown, you can return to the widgets.

Overall, operation via the touchscreen is smooth and precise. However, as the display remains cleaner, I use the crown and the buttons almost exclusively on the Pace 3.

Common Functions

As Coros offers GPS sports watches across its entire product portfolio and not smartwatches, the range of functions in everyday life is rather limited. The focus is on sport.

Display of daily activities on the Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Number of steps

The Pace 3 naturally records the steps you take throughout the day. It does this at a decent level, but is not directly comparable with other providers. Each brand uses its own algorithms.

Trend of the number of steps over the last few days on the Pace 3 display

Coros Pace 3 – Steps in the last few days

And to be honest, I don’t have to hit exactly 10,000 steps at the end of the day. If I want to increase my level of activity, I do it over a longer period of time. If the watch delivers values that deviate from reality, I don’t mind as long as it delivers these values consistently.

Representation of the heart rate trend over the last few hours Representation of sleep phases from last night on the watch display

In addition, the Pace 3 records the calories burned, the number of floors climbed and the heart rate/variability in the background. It also records sleep duration and phases.

It can calculate sleep duration quite accurately, but when it comes to sleep stages, I don’t trust it any more than any other watch. If you need a detailed analysis, that’s what sleep labs are made for…

When the paired smartphone is nearby, the Pace 3 mirrors notifications so you know if it’s worth reaching for your smartphone.

Display of a notification on the Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Display of notifications from the paired smartphone

As with all Coros watches, some metrics can only be analysed on the watch and not in the app. You don’t always need this, but I would like to see the number of floors climbed over time.

Display of the music player on the Coros Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Playback of MP3 files

The musical capabilities of the Pace 3 only impress me on paper. Yes, the watch can store and play up to 4 GB of MP3 files via Bluetooth. But since the transfer speed to the device is extremely slow, it’s no fun.

Finally, compared to the Pace 2, the Pace 3 can shine with a small new function: the weather forecast.

Display of the current weather on the Pace 3 display

Coros Pace 3 – Weather forecast on the watch

Weather forecast for the upcoming hours on the Pace 3 display Weather forecast for the upcoming days on the Pace 3 display

This is based on the current location and shows:

  • Temperature (current)
  • Temperature (highs and lows)
  • Temperature (wind chill)
  • Precipitation probability
  • Humidity
  • UV index
  • Wind speed/direction

It also includes forecasts for the next 6 hours and the next 7 days.

Sports Functions

When it comes to sports, the Pace 3 naturally has more to offer. Let me walk you through the range of functions step by step.

Pressing the crown opens the sports menu. Here, you can not only choose the sports you want to record but also find training plans, workouts, fitness tests, and a view of past recordings.

Display of the Pace 3 sports menu

Coros Pace 3 – Sports menu

By default, Coros offers sports profiles for 23 sports. Since that may not be sufficient for everyone, you can add custom sports profiles. Let me briefly illustrate this using the example of my new sport, “Walking the Dog,” then we can explain the sports profiles in general.

A sports profile is a logical wrapper around a set of settings and includes:

  • Profile name
  • Icon representation
  • Category
  • Data pages (number and layout)
  • Data fields (number)
  • Data fields (assignment of metrics)
  • Sport alarm

This repeats for each sports profile.

Defining a custom sports profile in the Coros app Defining a custom sports profile in the Coros app Defining a custom sports profile in the Coros app

You can also change some of the details for existing sports profiles. The name and icon, as well as the category, cannot be changed. However, for the predefined sports profiles, you can define more than one data page where up to 8 data fields can be displayed.

Selection of data pages and data fields for a sports profile in the Coros app Selection of data pages and data fields for a sports profile in the Coros app Selection of data pages and data fields for a sports profile in the Coros app

For alarms, you can set threshold values or durations. When these values are reached, the watch notifies you with vibration and beeps. The values include:

  • Distance
  • Pace
  • Cadence
  • Heart rate
  • Power
  • Nutrition intake

Standard settings include notifications after every kilometer traveled. Because not all metrics make sense for all sports, they differ from profile to profile.

Selection of distance alarm for a sports profile in the Coros app Selection of pace warning for a sports profile in the Coros app Selection of power warning for a sports profile in the Coros app

So much for the theoretical basics – let’s do some sports.

Coros Pace 3 on wrist with sports menu opened just before recording

Coros Pace 3 – Selected sports profile just before recording

Before starting, you select the appropriate sports profile via the sports menu. While the Pace 3 searches for GNSS signals and paired sensors, you can quickly modify some settings, including intervals.

Settings for interval training directly on the Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Ad-hoc interval training

When searching for satellite signals (e.g. GPS), the Pace 3 is among the very quick responders. Typically, a stable GNSS signal is available within a few seconds.

Coros Pace 3 during recording with display showing six data fields

Coros Pace 3 – Data page with 6 data fields

During the activity, the watch displays the data pages stored in the profile. They can be switched by swiping or using the digital crown.

Data page showing heart rate and heart rate zone on the Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Heart rate with heart rate zones

After the activity, the sports watch displays a variety of metrics collected during the activity. If you don’t find the peace to review the values on the display immediately after the activity, you can also view the recording at a later time.

Brief summary of the recorded activity directly on the Pace 3

Coros Pace 3 – Insight into recorded data

Selection of a recorded training on the Pace 3 Display of metrics on the Pace 3 Display of metrics on the Pace 3 Display of pace on the Pace 3 Display of pace zones on the Pace 3 Display of heart rate graph on the Pace 3 Display of heart rate zones on the Pace 3 Display of power measurement on the Pace 3 Display of step length on the Pace 3 Display of altitude graph on the Pace 3 Display of activity duration and recommended recovery time on the Pace 3 Display of lap or interval times on the Pace 3

After synchronizing, the data appears in the app in the same extent.

Evaluation of an activity in the Coros app - Route Evaluation of an activity in the Coros app - Metrics Evaluation of an activity in the Coros app - Curves Evaluation of an activity in the Coros app - Curves

Connection with external sensors

If the built-in sensors are not sufficient, the Pace 3 seamlessly connects via Bluetooth with almost any external sensor.

The watch doesn’t really care whether it’s a chest strap heart rate monitor, optical wristband heart rate monitor, Stryd sensors, or similar devices. Owners of numerous accessories will be pleased to know that more than one sensor of a type can be stored in the watch.

By the way, the Pace 3 does not support ANT+ – but that’s not a big deal anymore.

GNSS accuracy

For many products, accuracy in location tracking and heart rate monitoring determines success or failure. Let’s start with location tracking. Some might say GPS accuracy, but this is only partially true.

In addition to GPS, the Pace 3 supports GLONASS, Galileo, Beidou, and QZSS. However, you can only choose from:

  • GPS only
  • all satellite systems
  • all satellite systems + multiband

For my runs, the Pace 3 always had access to all GNSS and had to forego multiband because its use here in the outskirts of Berlin doesn’t add much value. At the same time, the deciduous forests in the area are sparse and don’t challenge the watch much.

Track recorded with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches

From some distance, the Pace 3 and its competitors seem to perform quite similar. The Garmin Forerunner 245 is perhaps the one that deviates most. Admittedly, it’s the oldest model in the test field.

On closer inspection, the differences to the Forerunner 245 become clear, while the Pace 3 presents a very uniform picture. The straightness of the lines sometimes gives rise to the suspicion that Coros is smoothing out the values a little. Personally, I think it’s fine for watches to do this in order to compensate for inaccuracies when determining location.

Detailed view of deviations in the track recorded with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches

In fact, in all areas of the run you can see how cleanly the sections are recorded by the Pace 3.

Detailed view of deviations in the track recorded with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches

Another attempt, this time in direct comparison with the Pace 2. From a bird’s eye view, everything still looks quite uniform…

Track recorded with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches

…but the differences become apparent when you take a closer look again. Once more, it’s the Forerunner 245 that takes different paths. But the Pace 2 also has to make do with a much older GPS chip, which is noticeable in the recorded data.

Detailed view of deviations in the track recorded with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches

Here again, you can see how solid the route tracking of the Pace 3 is. Even the significantly more expensive Polar Vantage V3 doesn’t perform better. Coros seems to have successfully focused on the antenna design of the Pace 3. The plastic housing undoubtedly contributes positively to this.

Detailed view of deviations in the track recorded with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches

No matter where you look at the corners and ends of the runs, the Coros Pace 3 delivers a great performance. Yes, it will certainly look different when running in the city centre, between narrow streets and tall buildings. But with a healthy mix of open spaces, terraced houses with a limited number of storeys and sections in the woods, the Pace 3 has nothing to hide.

Heart rate accuracy

To get an impression of the accuracy of the PPG sensor, the Pace 3 accompanied me during jogging, hiking, and on the ergometer. Let’s start with a steady 5 km run.

Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps

Like me, most products need some time to find their rhythm at the start of a run. This is not always characterised by precision in the first few metres, and the Polar H10 chest strap is not ideal either. However, this equalises out with all models after a short time.

Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps

Otherwise, all sensors cope well with the steady trend and seem to deliver identical values in terms of measurement accuracy. The deviations from the Polar H10 are very small. As a reminder: the more blue areas you see in the charts, the further apart the two devices are.

Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps

On the next attempt, the Coros Pace 2 stands out unpleasantly. This is actually something I haven’t experienced with it in recent years. Compared to the Polar H10 chest strap and the Polar Ignite 3, the gaps are smaller. However, there are still a few small outliers compared to the chest strap.

Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps

The deviations between the Pace 3 and the previous model are more erratic. Although they are only short periods, they come with large fluctuations.

Deviation between Coros Pace 3 and Coros Pace 2

The Pace 3 stumbling occasionally is evident in the first three intervals. However, it is in good company because the significantly more expensive Polar Vantage V3 shows the same issues in the following four intervals.

Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps

When only comparing the Pace 3 and the chest strap heart rate monitor as a reference, the outliers become a little clearer against an otherwise decent trend.

Heart rate trend during a sports activity measured with the Coros Pace 3 compared to other sports watches and chest straps

Subsequently, the blue area in the difference chart also increases.

The proximity to the chest strap heart rate monitor is also reflected in relatively high r² values. Only the Coros Heart Rate Monitor surpasses the Pace 3 with an r² value of 0.986, better than the Pace 3’s 0.953.

Chart showing heart rate measurement by the Coros Pace 3 compared to the Polar H10 Chart showing heart rate measurement by the Vantage V3 compared to the Polar H10 Chart showing heart rate measurement by the Coros Heart Rate Monitor compared to the Polar H10 Chart showing heart rate measurement by the Polar Verity Sense compared to the Polar H10

I could provide numerous such evaluations here; the picture is always the same: the Pace 3 demonstrates decent performance, even if the measurements here and there aren’t “spot-on”. Compared to the Pace 2, it seems to deliver more solid values.

Software

The Coros app is free for iOS and Android alike. While there may be more visually appealing apps, it stands out positively in terms of clarity and structuring.

Dashboard of the Coros App Display of the Display of the Display of the

Here and there the translations into German seem a little awkward, but nothing that you can’t accept with a smile. Especially for most readers here, who would probably choose the English language settings.

Battery Life

Coros claims a battery life of up to 17 days in smartwatch mode. This could be accurate considering the daily loss of about 6 percent.

Of course, I don’t wear a watch on my wrist for that long without exercising with it, so the battery runs out faster. The battery drains quickly when using all GNSS during sports, with GPS using both the L1 and L5 frequency bands, and additional music playback via Bluetooth.

Overall, the battery life seems very appealing to me. During the review, I had another, albeit older sports watch on my other wrist. This one demanded power much more frequently.

Coros Pace 3 - Verdict

Rating: 88%
Score: 88%
Pros
  • numerous sports functions
  • fast multi-band GPS
  • great value for money
Cons
  • slow USB data transfer
  • lots of plastic

With small but significant improvements, Coros has succeeded in giving the Pace 2 a worthy successor. Admittedly, the appearance is in need of improvement and does not reflect the inner values of the Pace 3.

At the same time, there is hardly a sports watch on the market that offers so many useful sports metrics and customisation options, coupled with a high level of connectivity.

The accuracy of the GNSS tracking is high, often even higher than that of significantly more expensive products. The Pace 3 also shows few anomalies in heart rate measurement and is pleasingly close to the chest strap heart rate monitor.

For me, the Pace 3 is definitely worth a recommendation, especially as the price of 249 euros is a challenge. The comparable Polar Pacer Pro and the Garmin Forerunner 255 are priced at €329 and €349 respectively (RRP). However, retail prices are already significantly lower, putting the Pace 3 under considerable pressure.

With Coros constantly updating older models with new features, the Pace 3 could be the more attractive choice. Polar and Garmin tend to remain more consistent with their mid-range products in terms of features.

Disclosure: The Coros Pace 3 to me by Coros, free of charge, at my request for testing. No conditions were attached to this review, and the opinions and experiences shared here reflect my entirely unbiased assessment of the product.

Der Beitrag Coros Pace 3 Review – Great value for money erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/coros-pace-3-review/feed/ 0
Coros Heart Rate Monitor Review https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/coros-heart-rate-monitor-review/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/coros-heart-rate-monitor-review/#respond Wed, 21 Feb 2024 15:57:16 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/?p=19545 You don't have to measure your heart rate on your wrist or with a chest strap. With the Heart Rate Monitor, Coros impressively demonstrates that this also works on the upper arm.

Der Beitrag Coros Heart Rate Monitor Review erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
Coros is well-known for its sports watches and unveiling a HR monitor for the upper arm came at a surprise. Though the kind of wearable is not entirely new, it constitutes a new product line at Coros. I had the opportunity to review the Coros Heart Rate Monitor.

Though Coros hasn’t gained as much market shares as Polar or Garmin, it is known for its sophisticated sports watches with extensive features at competitive prices. The Coros Pace 2 and now the Pace 3 are perhaps the most popular products.

Coros Heart Rate Monitor lying on a table

Coros Heart Rate Monitor

With the Heart Rate Monitor, Coros introduced a new wearable in July ’23, designed to precisely measure heart rate. Since the Q4/23, the Coros HRM has also been available in Germany. A good reason to take a closer look at the product.

Unboxing and First Impression

Coros distributes the Heart Rate Monitor in a rather inconspicuous packaging, roughly the size of a Ritter Sport chocolate bar, but with a bit more depth, of course.

A hand holding the box of the Coros Heart Rate Monitor

Unsurprisingly, the package contains the Heart Rate Monitor, a USB charging cable, and some paperwork.

The heart rate monitor connected to the USB charging cable

The charging cable is quite short at 25 cm, with a USB-A plug at one end and a proprietary connector with two pins at the other end. Magnets integrated into the connector ensure that the charging cable adheres to the sensor during charging. I really like the kind of plug as it easily attaches to the sensor.

When I first got my hands on the HRM, a couple of questions arose the heart because the strap hasn’t properly attached to the sensor. But let’s take it step by step…

Coros heart rate monitor band

The Coros Heart Rate Monitor consists of a sensor unit and a flexible textile strap. The latter can be adjusted in width and is opened and closed using a Velcro fastener.

Coros Heart Rate Monitor turned to one side to depict the slim profile

Thanks to the type of attachment, the sensor unit can be slid along the strap. But only if the Coros Heart Rate Monitor is attached as intended: When taken out of the box, it was clear right away that something was assembled incorrectly here. The inscription “Explore Perfection” was facing inward rather than outward and there was no opportunity for meaningful closure of the strap.

Not a big deal – with a little patience and the the press images at hand, I managed to set up the “correct” orientation of the strap.

In the end, this does not affect the performance of the product.

Coros Heart Rate Monitor – First steps

To start using the device, Coros couldn’t have made it any easier: The Heart Rate Monitor turns on as soon as it makes contact with the skin. As a result, Coros can omit buttons for turning the device on and off. But I’ll come back to some disadvantages of this approach.

Backside of the Coros Heart Rate Monitor showing the PPG sensors

Once activated the four green LEDs on the underside of the sensor unit light up. I know it’s five LED but the one in the middle never lid up. Additionally there is a small LED on the side that indicates the battery level when the device is turned on.

If the sensor is removed from the skin, the Heart Rate Monitor goes into standby mode shortly after.

Comfort

As the strap width often adjusts, the tricky part is putting the Heart Rate Monitor on. This might be different if you use the Velcro to open and close it. For simplicity’s sake, I just slip those straps over the upper arm.

Ends of the armband with velcro to easily open and close

Once the strap is in place, it stays there. Even during intense physical activity – the strap neither slips nor twists.

From my experience the comfort level is extremely high. At only 19 grams, the Heart Rate Monitor is very lightweight, with the sensor unit being flat and slim. So, during exercise, you hardly notice that the Coros HRM is constantly with you.

For better comparison of size, I placed alternative products from Wahoo, Polar, and Scosche next to it:

Comparison with other HR optical bands | Front sides

Comparison with other HR optical bands | Front sides

Comparison with other HR optical bands | Back sides

Comparison with other HR optical bands | Back sides

Connection via Bluetooth LE

The Coros HRM exclusively supports Bluetooth and requires it to share its data with smartphones, tablets, or computers. Because it lacks integrated storage, the device cannot run independently.

However, the Heart Rate Monitor supports up to three simultaneous Bluetooth connections, which can be useful, for example, when heart rate data is to be used in the Swift app and on the sports watch at the same time.

It’s noteworthy that the Coros HRM can be seamlessly paired with other devices and apps. Whenever I tried to pair with a Vantage V2/V3, a Grit X Pro, or a Ignite 3 from Polar, a Forerunner 245 and a Vivoactive 4 from Garmin, or many of the watches from Amazfit and Huawei, there were no issues with any of them.

The same applies to various apps on iOS or Android: The Coros HRM is recognized without any issues.

Seamless pairing via Bluetooth LE

Seamless pairing via Bluetooth LE

If you own a Coros sports watch, you’ll find that after setting up the Heart Rate Monitor via the app, the sensor has already been added to the watch and only needs to be selected when needed.

Battery Life of the Coros HRM

Coros claims a battery life of up to 38 hours when the sensor is on and collecting data. In standby mode, however, the HRM lasts up to 80 days on a single charge.

I think these are realistic values, although I didn’t have to recharge during the weeks reviewing the HRM. Keep in mind that the battery charge is sufficient for more than a month with daily usage of one hour. However, there’s a small caveat: Because you can’t turn the Heart Rate Monitor off, it remains active much longer than the actual physical activity lasts.

When I go running, it takes me a while to get everything together, fulfill the last wishes of my little daughter, and finally leave the house. And even after exercising, I like to sit in the garden for about 15 minutes to cool down. During this time, the sensor is still active, even if the recording on the watch may have already stopped.

In terms of battery life, this shouldn’t be a major drawback, but it’s something to be aware of.

Accuracy in Heart Rate Measurement

Examining the HRM’s accuracy is perhaps the most interesting part of this review. To gain the most comprehensive picture possible, the Coros HRM had to compete with the following devices:

  • Scosche Rhythm 24 (Test Report)
  • Polar Verity Sense (Test Report)
  • Wahoo TICKR Fit (Test Report)

As a reference for all optical heart rate sensors, I used the Polar H10 strap. It remains one of the best products on the market.

Let’s take a look at a few recordings, representative of pretty much all the experiences I’ve had with the Coros HRM.

It’s evident that none of the HR sensors show any weaknesses, even though it may seem like one or two devices are still settling in. By the start of the intervals, all products are on par.

If we focus on the comparison between the Coros HRM and the Polar H10 as a reference, it appears that the HR chest strap is lagging a bit behind in the recording. Experience shows that it should actually be the other way around. Perhaps the internal clocks of the Amazfit Cheetah Pro and the Garmin Forerunner 245 were not quite synchronized, as both devices were used to record heart rate data.

Looking solely at the difference between the Polar H10 and Coros HRM, there is indeed a slight time offset, but no significant deviating values.

The strong correlation between the Polar H10 and the Coros HRM is evident in the coefficient of determination of 0.968.

The Polar Verity Sense and the Scosche Rhythm 24 perform slightly better.

The accuracy during exercise on the ergometer doesn’t show any significant differences either. Here, all products are close together, if anything can be distinguished in the “curve mess” at all. Therefore, I’ve illustrated the deviations between the individual HR sensors.

Between the reference device Polar H10 and the Coros HRM, there are practically no differences. The curves are almost identical, and if there are any small deviations, they are in the correct order: the optical sensor of the Coros HRM is slightly slower than the HR chest strap.

This is also evident in the difference graph, where there is little blue area. Just as a reminder: The larger the blue areas between the two curves, the greater the differences between the two recordings.

In a direct comparison between the Coros wearable and Polar’s optical HR sensor, there is little to complain about. The minor deviations are temporary and are not significant in either ad-hoc or overall consideration.

Coros’s Heart Rate Monitor is on par with the Scosche Rhythm 24 to such an extent that I briefly wondered if I had made a mistake in the recording or assignment. But no, everything seems to be fine.

The difference from the Wahoo TICKR Fit is more pronounced.

The very good performance is evident again in the high values of R². With 0.991, the Coros HRM edges past the Polar Verity Sense. The Scosche Rhythm 24 is just a tad above with 0.998.

Another attempt and a well-known result: When running with a warm-up and a few intervals, the curves mostly align. Only during the warm-up phase, the HR sensors seem to warm up a bit themselves, and there are moments of baseline noise. Surprisingly, the Polar Verity Sense and the Scosche Rhythm 24 show two deviations during the intervals.

In a direct comparison between the HR strap and the Coros HRM, there’s nothing to complain about. The curves are almost identical, and highlighting the minimal differences would draw too much attention to discrepancies that aren’t significant.

For the first time, the Coros HRM also achieves the best value for the coefficient of determination, “following” the Polar H10’s values the best. Apart from the TICKR Fit, the other products are not far behind, and each of the strap has delivered very good performance so far.

Did I ever manage to trip up the Coros HRM in the test? Honestly, no! Even when looking for “worse” results, the competing products similarly showed some discrepancies, with most variations occurring in the first few minutes of recording.

Sometimes you can observe R² values as low as 0.95 which are still excellent.

To sum up: the Coros HRM performance is excellent, matching the Polar Verity Sense and the Scosche Rhythm 24 while outperforming the Wahoo TICKR Fit.

Coros Heart Rate Monitor - Verdict

Rating: 88%
Score: 88%
Pros
  • precise heart rate measurement
  • low weight
  • slim
Cons
  • no onboard memory
  • there are better solutions for less money

Accuracy is paramount for a heart rate sensor, and the Coros HRM excels in this regard. So far, I have not experienced any anomalies during the review – on the contrary, the Heart Rate Monitor competes on par with the established leaders, the Polar Verity Sense and the Scosche Rhythm 24, delivering essentially the same values as an HR chest strap.

Its small size and easy handling are positive aspects, disregarding the slight inconvenience of putting it on. The battery life is generous, and even with an empty battery, it can be fully charged within 2 hours.

However, the Coros HRM faces some challenges. In my opinion, this is primarily due to two factors:

  • Lack of Memory

    Although it might seem like nitpicking, both the Verity Sense and the Rhythm 24 have integrated memory, allowing them to store HR data directly without the need for a sports watch or smartphone. This provides even more flexibility and enables their use in water activities.

  • Price-Performance Ratio

    With a suggested retail price of €79, the Coros HRM’s price is reasonable. However, it cannot compensate for the lack of memory or the ecosystem provided by Polar. While the Polar Verity Sense has a suggested retail price of €99, it is already available in stores for around €70. The Scosche Rhythm 24 is currently available directly from the Scosche for as low as €49, although it seems to be a clearance price, and the Scosche’s app is not the best. Nevertheless, both of these options offer a more attractive price-performance ratio at the moment.

Overall, the Coros Heart Rate Monitor is still an intriguing product that won’t disappoint. If the prices in retail drop a bit more, the HRM will become even more appealing.

One more thing...

Can you imagine that this is a privately-run website? There's no office or editorial staff here, just me with a lot of passion and motivation to provide information, reviews, and news in a manner that large online magazines simply can't match. Even if English is not my first language, I hope you found this article useful.

If you'd like to support this website or show appreciation for my work, please leave a comment, share a link, or use the Amazon link to buy anything (it doesn't have to be related to the subject of this article). It would be much appreciated and will support this website.

Disclosure: The Heart Rate Monitor to me by Coros, free of charge, at my request for testing. No conditions were attached to this review, and the opinions and experiences shared here reflect my entirely unbiased assessment of the product.

Der Beitrag Coros Heart Rate Monitor Review erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/coros-heart-rate-monitor-review/feed/ 0
Suunto Wing Review – Sound through bone conduction https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/suunto-wing-review-sound-through-bone-conduction/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/suunto-wing-review-sound-through-bone-conduction/#respond Fri, 22 Dec 2023 14:40:52 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/?p=19588 Suunto unveiled the Suunto Wing - a bone conduction headphone for athletes that allows for listening to music while remaining aware of the surroundings.

Der Beitrag Suunto Wing Review – Sound through bone conduction erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
Suunto unveiled a sports headphone – a news that I first considered as an April Fool’s joke. However, the Suunto Wing is a reality and it’s a headphone that utilizes bone conduction technology. I had the opportunity to test and review it.

Suunto Wing

Suunto Wing

In a bold departure from their traditional focus on sports diving devices and rugged outdoor sports watches, Finnish company Suunto has surprisingly ventured into the realm of audio technology. The latest addition marks a significant leap into uncharted territory for the renowned brand.

In this article, I will explore the features, design, and performance of the Suunto Wing, delving into how they stand out from the competition and what sets them apart from traditional sport headphones.

Bone Conduction – What is it?

What makes the Suunto Wing special is certainly the bone conduction technology, where sound doesn’t reach the inner ear through the air and eardrum, but rather conjures music into the ears via the cheekbones.

For this, so-called transducers are placed in front of the ears and transmit the sounds through vibrations to the bones.

The major advantage of this is that the headphones don’t exclude environmental sound, as is the case with in-ear or over-ear headphones. This allows the users to continue perceiving their surroundings, and even engage in conversations seamlessly.

Unboxing and First Impression

Suunto packages the Wing in an attractive, white box reminiscent in size of a thick paperback book.

Packaging of Suunto Wing

Packaging of Suunto Wing

Pictures speak louder than a thousand words, so it’s best to see for yourself.

Contents of the packaging

Contents of the packaging

Once unfolded, the headphones can be found on the left side, already placed in the small power bank, which is also part of the overall package.

Storage pouch
Earplugs for enhanced bass

In the other half of the packaging, there’s a storage pouch, a USB charging cable, a pair of earplugs, and the obligatory printed materials (warranty and safety instructions, quick guide).

First Impression

Visually, the Suunto Wing closely resembles the OpenRun Pro by Shokz. Shokz is indeed the pioneer, and almost all bone conduction headphones currently exhibit the design of the forefather of this headphone technology.

Suunto Wing

Suunto Wing

However, the Suunto Wing speaks its own language, as the transducers come in a sleek, sporty red color.

Transducers with logo

Transducers with logo

The fact that the company name is also written on them appeals to me, but I’m easily impressed by such details.

At 33 grams, the headphones are naturally lightweight.

Buttons, including volume control

Buttons, including volume control

The craftsmanship leaves a very high-quality impression. There’s simply nothing to complain about. Gaps are so minimal that there’s hardly anything to write about here.

Compared to the Shokz OpenRun Pro, both the transducers and the electronic unit behind the ear are slightly larger. However, this is not noticeable in everyday use.

Suunto Wing vs. Shokz OpenRun Pro
Suunto Wing vs. Shokz OpenRun Pro

Thanks to its solid construction, the Suunto Wing is IP67 water and dust resistant, making it resistant to sweat as well.

Comfort

And the comfort? It’s high and strongly reminiscent of the Shokz models here too, meaning the headphones sit almost imperceptibly on the ears. Even with sunglasses and a bicycle helmet, the Suunto Wing fits easily on the head. A bit of practice for the “right” fit and especially the sequence of when to put on what, everyone has to figure out for themselves.

It gets a little trickier in winter when hats are supposed to keep the head and ears warm. It’s still doable, but with some minor compromises – either in comfort or the temperature of the ears.

If there’s something noticeable, it’s the fairly generously sized band that connects the transducers and the technology behind the head. But this ensures that it definitely fits on every head.

First Steps and Features

There usually isn’t much to say about setting up a headphone, and that’s also the case with the Suunto Wing: Pairing mode is initiated with a button press, so that a smartphone, tablet or watch and the headphones quickly find each other.

Even faster is NFC, because then the Suunto Wing only needs to be held near the NFC-enabled device (e.g., smartphone or tablet). The devices recognize the headphones and automatically ask if they should be paired.

Otherwise, it’s just a matter of getting familiar with the operation of the Suunto Wing. There’s not much to learn there:

ActionContextButtonResult
1x pressaudio playbackmultifunction buttonplay / pause
2x pressaudio playbackmultifunction buttonnext track
3x pressaudio playbackmultifunction buttonprevious track
1x press (long)-multifunction buttonLED on / off
1x presscallmultifunction buttonanswer / reject call

Control with Head Movement

Even easier and particularly suitable for sports is control via head movement. Although this feature needs to be activated and drains the battery a bit faster, it allows you to skip to the next track or answer a call with a simple nod of the head.

If you’re not in the mood or too out of breath for a phone call, all you need to do is shake your head.

It’s a cool feature that I missed on the Shokz models. However, it takes a bit of getting used to performing the movement correctly. It has to be executed very clearly and cleanly – a bit like checking the mirrors during a driving test.

After a bit of practice, it works mostly problem-free and is a real asset when your hands aren’t free or you don’t want to fumble with your smartphone or watch while exercising.

Light Strips for Increased Visibility

Another unique feature is the three red LEDs that Suunto has installed on both sides of the headphones, which can be turned on and off with the press of a button.

LED light strips on both sides

LED light strips on both sides

To enhance visibility even further, you can switch from continuous lighting to blinking, offered with various intervals.

LED light strips in the dark

LED light strips in the dark

Although the solution itself is good, the LEDs could have been a bit brighter. For my sense of security, I also attach a light to my hat or a glowing band to my arm.

Phone Calls with the Suunto Wing

For me, phone calls aren’t the primary function of bone conduction headphones, but thanks to the built-in microphone, even phone calls work with the Suunto Wing when paired with a phone.

To ensure you don’t miss any calls, the headphones offer two different ring modes – a normal one for quieter environments and a louder one for when you don’t want to miss a call.

Up to 30 km/h, the Suunto Wing should also be able to suppress wind noise while cycling, although you won’t notice much of it yourself.

Areas of Use and Sound Quality

Normally, sound quality essentially determines the quality of headphones. With bone conduction headphones, I wanted to make an exception because sound quality is deliberately sacrificed for safety. Because this goes hand in hand with the area of use, I’ll share my assessment of both points here together.

  • Sound Quality

    Let’s start with sound quality: Anyone who puts on bone conduction headphones and expects a performance similar to that of in-ear or over-ear headphones will be disappointed.

    Objectively speaking, the Suunto Wing (and all other bone conduction headphones) fail to deliver the depth of sound that in-ear and over-ear headphones offer. The reasons are varied, but the most significant is the lack of shielding from ambient noise.

    For this purpose, Suunto also includes the two earplugs. Once inserted into the ear (alternatively, your fingers can do the job), even tones a few octaves lower are perceived.

    I didn’t notice any weakness in the midrange and treble with the Suunto Wing. However, the declining bass range makes the overall sound rather flat.

  • Areas of Use

    But, and this is a big but: Here, you’re consciously trading musical quality for safety. Even someone who has only jogged in the forest with music playing through in-ear or over-ear headphones knows the horror of an overtaking cyclist.

    I don’t think I need to describe situations in traffic here. Everyone knows that ears must remain free if you value your own health.

    And that’s exactly where the Suunto Wing with bone conduction technology comes in: Hearing remains open to ambient noises. You’ll notice an approaching car just as much as a bicycle bell.

    And let’s be honest: When I’m out exercising, I need music for entertainment, not for audiophile enjoyment. For podcasts, audio dramas, and beats for motivation, the Suunto Wing is fantastic.

For pure musical enjoyment with fine detailing and stage presentation, there are better products and places.

Battery Life

Suunto states that the battery life of the Wing can last up to 10 hours on a full charge. However, the test period was not sufficient to fully deplete the battery.

Powerbank with up to 2 additional charges

Powerbank with up to 2 additional charges

If the battery does run low, the small and lightweight power bank can provide the headphones with up to two additional full charges.

Charging directly on the headphones

Charging directly on the headphones

And apparently, for me and many others who tend to forget to charge their devices in time, the fast charging mechanism can provide the battery with enough energy for up to three hours of runtime after just 10 minutes of charging. If necessary, power can also be supplied directly to the headphones via the USB cable.

I believe these are dimensions that should be sufficient for the vast majority of users.

Suunto Wing - Verdict

Rating: 95%
Score: 95%
Reviewing the Suunto Wing was a lot of fun, especially because one might think there aren’t many innovations in the headphone segment that are advantageous for sports. Suunto has proven that small but meaningful improvements can make a difference.

Controlling the phones via head movement may not be a feature used daily, but it’s a great addition for those who don’t want or can’t use their hands. The LED lights are likely to be used much more, especially in autumn and winter.

And the sound? It’s great for headphones that offer so much safety. It may not be Dolby standard, but it’s more than sufficient for sports.

At 199 €, the Suunto Wing are slightly more expensive than the Shokz OpenRun Pro. However, the price is justified for the additional features, and it’s up to each individual whether they want to pay the extra 20 € for those features.

I can highly recommend both the Suunto Wing and the Shokz OpenRun Pro to everyone.

One more thing...

Can you imagine that this is a privately-run website? There's no office or editorial staff here, just me with a lot of passion and motivation to provide information, reviews, and news in a manner that large online magazines simply can't match. Even if English is not my first language, I hope you found this article useful.

If you'd like to support this website or show appreciation for my work, please leave a comment, share a link, or use the Amazon link to buy anything (it doesn't have to be related to the subject of this article). It would be much appreciated and will support this website.

Der Beitrag Suunto Wing Review – Sound through bone conduction erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/suunto-wing-review-sound-through-bone-conduction/feed/ 0
RingConn Smart Ring Review – Unobtrusive fitness tracking for 7 days https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/ringconn-smart-ring-test/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/ringconn-smart-ring-test/#respond Sun, 15 Oct 2023 13:54:17 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/?p=18485 RingConn is one of the companies that not only advertise a Smart Ring but have already brought it to market. Here, you find pretty much any detail about RingConn's Smart Ring as I have reviewed it for two weeks.

Der Beitrag RingConn Smart Ring Review – Unobtrusive fitness tracking for 7 days erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
RingConn is one of the companies that not only advertise a Smart Ring but have already brought it to market. In this review, you find pretty much any detail about RingConn’s Smart Ring as well as my experience during a two-week test.

Activity trackers in the form of wristbands became popular about 10 years ago. Since then, little has been changed and most wearables are worn around the wrist.

As nothing is as steady as change, some companies have attempted to mold the concept of fitness trackers into ring form. So far, the market has been relatively quiet, with Oura, the company behind the eponymous ring, causing a stir.

RingConn Smart Ring in Moonlit Silver and Pale Gold

RingConn Smart Ring in Moonlit Silver and Pale Gold

RingConn’s Smart Ring challenges Oura’s smart ring, which currently holds the pole position. In this review, I will delve into the features, advantages, disadvantages, and comfort of RingConn’s wearable.

Sizing Kit for the right size

Unlike fitness trackers and sports watches worn on the wrist, a smart ring cannot flexibly adjust its size. Because the correct ring size must be known before purchase, RingConn offers a free sizing kit that contains plastic blanks in nine different sizes.

RingConn’s Free Sizing Kit

RingConn’s Free Sizing Kit

This not only allows you to try out the correct ring size but also get in touch with the small sensors on the inside of the ring.

Even though they are only blanks, they have the same dimensions as the smart ring, and wearing such a blank for a day to see which size fits was invaluable to me – otherwise, I would have chosen a size too large.

Samples of different ring sizes

Samples of different ring sizes

Additionally, the sizing kit includes three small metal plates in the colors in which the Smart Ring can be ordered. This way you get a pretty good impression of how the ring will look like. The available options are:

  • Pale Gold
  • Moonlit Silver
  • Midnight Black

The sizing kit can be ordered for free from RingConn.

Unboxing and First Impressions

Since the product reached me directly from the Asia, there were a few days between providing the ring size and the arrival of the smart ring itself. These were days during which my anticipation and curiosity about my first steps with a smart ring started to grow.

Appealing Packaging of the RingConn Smart Ring

Appealing Packaging of the RingConn Smart Ring

RingConn delivers the Smart Ring in an appealing 10 x 10 x 9 cm black cardboard box.

Upon opening, the first thing you see is the Smart Ring. Beneath it is the charging case, a quick guide, and the USB charging cable (USB-A to USB-C).

RingConn’s Smart Ring in the packaging

RingConn’s Smart Ring in the packaging

The product is presented in an attractive manner, showcasing the ring nicely.

Of course, appearance is a very subjective feeling, but the Smart Ring from RingConn convinces me in this regard. It has a square-round shape, with the outer part being more square with generously rounded corners, but the inner part is almost circular.

Square-round shape of the RingConn Smart Ring

Square-round shape of the RingConn Smart Ring

It’s the sensors and charging connectors inside the ring that require a little space and prevent a perfectly circular shape.

However, you don’t notice this when wearing it, and the ring is so light, weighing only 3-5 grams (depending on the size), that you hardly notice it after a couple of days.

For me, it took a few days to forget about the ring as such, mainly because the ring is almost twice as wide as my wedding bainnd. You can feel it at the beginning mostly due to habit but you get used to it quite quickly. If I could wish for something, I would find a slimmer smart ring even more appealing.

There’s nothing to fault about the ring, as the craftsmanship is flawless. While I initially had concerns about the finish and the material’s surface, I now handle the ring much more casually. Gardening, DIY, washing dishes, showering – none of these activities have harmed the material or the ring so far.

Thanks to its IP68 rating, the ring is well protected against water and dust.

Packed with Technology

What you can’t see from the outside, is the smart ring’s technological interior. The RingConn team has integrated LEDs (1x red, 2x green), photodiodes, and an accelerometer into this slim band.

Optical sensors and charging port

Optical sensors and charging port

Additionally, the ring houses a memory that can store data for up to 7 days. A small battery powers the ring for the same period. If the battery ever runs low, it can be fully charged within about an hour in the charging case. Because the charging case itself has a 500 mAh battery, the RingConn Smart Ring can be charged without a USB power source.

Charging case for the smart ring

In order to check the battery level, you have to use the app. The ring itself has neither an status LED nor a vibration motor to provide any information to the user.

Since I recently came across the Misfit Shine 2, I immediately wished to somehow find such tiny LEDs in a smart ring.

I’m confident that over the years, we’ll see significantly smaller smart rings with more feedback options.

RingConn Smart Ring vs. Oura Ring

I haven’t had the opportunity to try out the Oura Ring yet, but I can compare both product spec-wise:

RingConn Smart RingOura Ring
SizeWidth: 7.8 mm
Thickness: 2.6 mm
Width: 7.9 mm
Thickness: 2.55 mm
Weight3 - 5 g4 - 6 g
Material- Titanium
- PVD coating
- non-metallic inner part
- Titanium
- PVD coating
- non-metallic inner part
Sensors- Motion sensor
- LED (green, red, infrared)
- Temperatur
- Motion sensor
- LED (green, red, infrared)
- Temperatur
Battery life7 days7 days
Price$279$299 + subscription

As you can see, both rings are quite similar in terms of technical specifications, but differ considerably in price. The RingConn Smart Ring is not only $20 cheaper, but also does not require a subscription, which costs an additional $5.99 per month for the Oura Ring.

RingConn Smart Ring in Everyday Life

Setup

Before diving into the features of the Smart Ring from RingConn, I’d like to briefly discuss the initial steps with the ring. Despite there not being much to report, that’s precisely the point: dealing with the ring and the app is incredibly straightforward.

The ring doesn’t offer any form of user interaction. Therefore, the only thing left to do is to charge the ring and then put it on your finger. You are free to choose any finger that the ring does fit on. The only limitation is that the ring’s sensors rest against the inside of the hand.

The app is available for free on both iOS and Android. Before setting the ring up, you have to create an account with RingConn. To ensure everything is in compliance with data protection regulations, you must also specify your country. Subsequently, the data is stored in compliance with the GDPR as I live in Germany.

Creating and confirming the user account takes just 2-3 minutes, and then the magic begins.

Features

After almost 10 years of dealing with various wearables, the RingConn Smart Ring stands out because it’s refreshingly different – mainly because you can’t interact with the ring or even directly obtain information from it.

It is a purely passive companion in daily life. Occasionally, it quietly shares its data with the app. This includes:

  • Heart rate
  • Heart rate variability (HRV)
  • Resting heart rate
  • Blood oxygen saturation (SpO2)
  • Activity data
  • Sleep duration and phases
  • Skin temperature

Though this seem pretty basic for fitness trackers, it is the current state of the art for smart rings. Fairly, the ring has less space and sensors available.

Regarding activity data, it’s mainly steps, the calorie consumption, and the hours of being active that complement the metrics.

The app, currently available in English and Chinese only, is divided into two sections.

Analysis of Daily Data in the “Insights” Section

In the “Insights” section, you can delve into the metrics of a specific day, grouped by:

  • Sleep data
  • Activity data
  • Stress

Although this section revolves around the values of the selected day, you can see the activity and sleep data compared to the averages of the previous week..

Dashboard with current daily values 1/4
Dashboard with current daily values 2/4
Dashboard with current daily values 3/4
Dashboard with current daily values 4/4

On the dashboard, you can also find the timeline, which contains automatically generated messages but can also be supplemented with your own notes.

Tapping on one of the categories takes you to the detailed views. RingConn tries to combine numerous individual values into one score, but the very detailed graphics and values quickly outweigh them.

Detailed sleep analysis 1/4
Detailed sleep analysis 2/4
Detailed sleep analysis 3/4
Detailed sleep analysis 4/4

What might seem overwhelming at first gradually reveals a structured layout over time. However, you need to immerse yourself a bit in the app. If you only want to work with a handful of metrics, you’ll need to quickly learn where to look in the app.

Detailed activity analysis 1/4
Detailed activity analysis 2/4
Detailed activity analysis 3/4
Detailed activity analysis 4/4

For those who are not familiar with every health metric, RingConn has provided a brief explanation for almost every metric. So, if you’re unsure about what “heart rate variability” means, you’ll find the appropriate explanation in the app. The English translation is flawless.

Analysis in the “Trends” section

In the “Trends” section, the values of longer periods (weeks, months, years) are compared with each other.

Dashboard of the
Dashboard of the
Dashboard of the

On the dashboard, you can find metrics like the number of steps, sleep duration, stress level, and heart rate. If you want to delve deeper, the details are just a tap away.

Here, the app categorizes the sections as follows:

  • Sleep
  • Activities
  • Stress
  • Other

If you look into one of the sections, you will get numerous analyses that other companies might shy away from.

Weekly sleep analysis 1/4
Weekly sleep analysis 2/4
Weekly sleep analysis 3/4
Weekly sleep analysis 4/4

Here are a few examples:

  • Stress level (average)
  • Morning stress level
  • Afternoon stress level
  • Evening stress level
Weekly stress level analysis 1/3
Weekly stress level analysis 2/3
Weekly stress level analysis 3/3

These qualitative analyses are complemented by quantitative analyses:

  • Duration of low-stress periods
  • Duration of normal stress periods
  • Duration of moderate stress periods
  • Duration of high-stress periods

As you can see, the level of detail is very high, covering almost every aspect of the collected values.

It would be great if the notes added to the timeline could somehow be reconciled with the analyses. For example, if you had a few drinks with friends, you can enter it, but currently there is no indication in the analyses that the subsequent poor sleep could be due to alcohol consumption.

Accuracy of data

What makes the comparison of data a bit challenging is that RingConn doesn’t provide a way to export the data. However, the company has implemented data transfer to Google Fit and Apple Health.

So, I looked at the aggregated values rather than the trends:

RingConn Smart RingAmazfit Balance
Resting heart rate (avg)64.2964.49
HRV (avg)40.7137.71
Heart rate (max)134135
Heart rate (min)4849
Heart rate (avg)7777
Accuracy heart rate readings

Notably, the “simple” heart rate measurements are quite close to each other. In the case of heart rate variability, the RingConn app consistently shows higher values. I’ll be monitoring this more closely in the coming weeks and months.

This is necessary because RingConn is continuously providing improvements and extensions in the form of firmware updates. The company has already announced an update that will bring a new “Activity Tracking” feature. It remains to be seen whether this will result in more accurate heart rate data during exercise, as the ring consistently reports low values in this context.

I will continue wearing the ring for some time to see where it leads.

RingConn Smart Ring Review – Conclusion

The RingConn Smart Ring is a small but impressive wearable. For a debut product, it performs quite remarkable. This compact ring is not only solidly constructed and lives up to its promised 7-day battery life but also captures metrics that you would expect from good fitness trackers.

The recorded values are not significantly better or worse than those of sports watches or fitness bands in the same price range. Of course, there are variations here and there, but that also happens when comparing fitness trackers and sports watches. Each company seems to have its own way of doing things.

What I particularly like about the RingConn Smart Ring is its unobtrusiveness and passivity. Few other wearables require so little attention or offer so little distraction. For those who find fitness trackers and sports watches too intrusive but are still interested in metrics related to health and activity, the RingConn Smart Ring provides a great alternative.

It is to be hoped that the development of smart rings does not stop and that the many emerging products make it to market readiness.

Disclosure: The RingConn Smart Ring to me by RingConn, free of charge, at my request for testing. No conditions were attached to this review, and the opinions and experiences shared here reflect my entirely unbiased assessment of the product.

Der Beitrag RingConn Smart Ring Review – Unobtrusive fitness tracking for 7 days erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/ringconn-smart-ring-test/feed/ 0
Mighty Vibe Review – Listen to Spotify and Amazon Music even without the Internet https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/mighty-vibe-test/ https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/mighty-vibe-test/#respond Wed, 22 Jun 2022 09:34:14 +0000 https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/mighty-vibe-test/ The Mighty Vibe is a small music player that allows for storing and playing back offline playlists from Spotify or Amazon Music. It's way smaller than a smartphone and way less expensive than Garmin's sport watches that offer the same.

Der Beitrag Mighty Vibe Review – Listen to Spotify and Amazon Music even without the Internet erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
Listening to Spotify or Amazon Music when you are doing sports requires a – more or less bulky – smartphone or one of Garmin’s more expensive sports watches. The Mighty Vibe is a small and affordable music player that is able to store offline playlists from Spotify and Amazon Music. It even updates dynamic playlists on its own.

Mighty Vibe

Mighty Vibe

Doing sports without music is possible, but pointless – nah, not really but when listening to music many things become more easy. If Spotify and Amazon Music are your preferred source of music, there are two ways to enjoy their content:

  • You have a smartphone connected to the internet, so that the streaming service is used directly
  • You have downloaded an offline playlist on your smartphone, smartwatch or sports watchs

When it comes to watches, only a few products allow for offline playlists. Among sports watches, only Garmin supports downloading and playing back content from Spotify and/or Amazon Music.

However, both smartphones and sports watches have disadvantages: Smartphones tend to be quite big and heavy these days, while Garmin’s sports watches are pretty expensive.

The Mighty Vibe is one of those rare devices that can store content from Spotify as well as Amazon Music and play it back on headphones or speakers via Bluetooth.

Unboxing and first impression

The Mighty Vibe is sold in a black cardboard box whose format is most reminiscent of a Nokia 6210. Inside is the small square music player, a tiny leaflet with quick-start instructions and a description of the multi-coloured LED located on the front of the Vibe.

Mighty Vibe - box

A short USB cable with a proprietary plug is used to supply power. And that’s it – there is nothing else in the box.

Mighty Vibe - box content

With a size of approx. 38 x 38 x 19 mm and a weight of only 19 grams, the Mighty Vibe is one of the lightweights. After all, the small device has a built-in battery that provides 5+ hours of musical accompaniment. 8 GB offer enough space for many hours of music.

The Vibe somewhat reminds me of the iPod Shuffle – even if it doesn’t look quite as graceful.

Mighty Vibe and Apple iPod Shuffle

The control pad on the front is used to control the volume and to skip tracks. The central button starts and pauses playback and can be pressed and held to turn off the vibe. The button at the top right is used to select or to jump to the next playlist.

Because the control pad and the buttons have a firm pressure point, you can tell for sure whether the key has been pressed, even in the heat of the moment.

Mighty Vibe clip

There is a clip on the back, which ensures a secure hold on whereever you attach it – usually you do so on clothing. I don’t share the criticism voiced here and there that the Vibe does not hold tight enough. Due to its weight (even if it’s leightweight) I would not attach it to the collar of a thin T-shirt, but there are no problems attaching it to a waistband or mid-layer.

Mighy App

The Mighty Vibe doesn’t work without the Mighty App that is free for iOS and Android. It is necessary for setting up the music player and for uploading content. Despite being rather simple, it serves its purpose and is reminiscent – intentionally or not – of the Bauhaus principle: form follows function.

Setting the Mighty Vibe up

The Vibe is set up within 5 minutes: You need to subscribe to a free Mighty account first, but I’m not sure what it’s good for. After pairing the Mighy Vibe to your smartphone / tablet, you have to enter your Wi-Fi credentials so that the Vibe may update dynamic playlists on its own. And that’s it – you are ready to go.

If you use both Spotify and Amazon Music, you have to choose between the two services. If you switch between the platforms, all content previously transferred to the Vibe will be deleted. Mighty said, that they are working on an update that allows for storing content from both plattforms side by side.

Mighty App at a Glance

The app is divided into three sections:

  • Connections

    Whether the connection to the Mighty itself, headphones/speakers paired via Bluetooth, access to the WLAN or the connection data to Spotify / Amazon Music – everything can be found in this part of the app. This is also where your Mighty Vibe experience will start, as a Wi-Fi connection and connection to one of the streaming services are required for transferring content to the Vibe.

  • New Content

    In this part of the app you can find playlists – yours or the ones offered by Spotify / Amazon Music. Mighty is not quite as convenient as the original apps, but your own playlists, the ones you listened to last and a collection of workout playlists are displayed immediately. All other content is subject to the search function.

    Recently, a category with curated playlists of popular Disney film music was added.

  • Synced Content

    If content has been transferred to the Vibe, the corresponding playlist can be found here and – if necessary – can also be deleted from here.

To transfer playlists to the Vibe, you simply mark them and then are transferred to the Vibe as part of the synchronisation. Unfortunately, the music player can only connect to 2.4 GHz networks and it does need the network as transferring data via Bluetooth would be much too slow. However, the speed is still not impressive and if you are familiar with the transfer speed of Garmin’s Forerunner 245 Music, you might feel a bit dizzy.

A playlist of 100 songs, is downloaded in about 10 – 20 minutes. I can’t give you exact numbers, because different file sizes result in different times. Spotify users can also choose between three different quality levels, which also result in different file sizes.

Content that has already been downloaded to the Vibe can be easily deleted via the app. The battery status and remaining storage space can only be viewed in the app.

The “Stay Fresh” feature allows for keeping already downloaded playlists up-to-date. If the playlist’s content changes, Stay Fresh ensures that any new content will be on the Vibe while old content will be removed.

On the road with the Mighty Vibe

Whether the Vibe is clamped on or carried in the hand is up to you. I actually like to carry it in my hand because I skip one song or another depending on my mood and the easiest way to do so is to hold it the Vibe in my hand.

It also makes a good impression when worn on a waistband or in a jacket pocket, although controlling the device is then somewhat more difficult.

Because you can control the Mighty Vibe with just one hand, you don’t get out of rhythm so easily when doing sports. I hate when I have to stop in order to press some buttons on my watch or even control something on my smartphone. Usually I get out of rhythm then and thus the Vibe is perfect for me.

The Vibe has a dedicated button to quickly change playlists. When you press the button, the next playlist’s name is read aloud. This is a completely different kind of entertainment, when the playlist’s name are not in English. However, with some guessing you’ll get the name.

Verdict – Mighty Vibe Test

The Mighty Vibe is a good and inexpensive music player for playing music from Spotify and Amazon Music without being connected to the Internet. The Vibe app is primarily used for setting the device up and for transferring content; for searching and compiling playlists, it’s often better to use the Spotify or Amazon Music app. This doesn’t make the product worse – I would call it a good division of tasks.

Apart from the price, the Vibe is convincing in two respects: First, there is the ease of use. The use is limited to playing and skipping tracks and playlists, but doesn’t require anything else. Second, download speeds are way better than it’s the case with my Garmin Forerunner 245 Music. So if you want to get a musical boost from Spotify or Amazon during your workout, the Vibe is for you.

There is also a minor disadvantage, because you cannot copy MP3 files the Vibe. The poor app stability, which was criticised by Amazon customers last year and the year before, seems to have been eliminated. I had no problems with either iOS or Android.

Mighty Vibe
203
Bewertungen
124,99 €
Aktueller Preis
99,99
UVP
Bewertungen ansehen Bei Amazon kaufen
Diese Webseite lebt durch dich. Kaufst du etwas über die Links, erhalte ich eine kleine Provision, die mir erlaubt die Webseite weiterhin werbefrei zu halten.

One more thing...

Can you imagine that this is a privately-run website? There's no office or editorial staff here, just me with a lot of passion and motivation to provide information, reviews, and news in a manner that large online magazines simply can't match. Even if English is not my first language, I hope you found this article useful.

If you'd like to support this website or show appreciation for my work, please leave a comment, share a link, or use the Amazon link to buy anything (it doesn't have to be related to the subject of this article). It would be much appreciated and will support this website.

Der Beitrag Mighty Vibe Review – Listen to Spotify and Amazon Music even without the Internet erschien zuerst auf Fitness Tracker Test.

]]>
https://www.fitness-tracker-test.info/en/mighty-vibe-test/feed/ 0